The Fountain of Stem Cell-Based Youth? Online Portrayals of Anti-Aging Stem Cell Technologies

Abstract

Background

The hype surrounding stem cell science has created a market opportunity for the cosmetic industry. Cosmetic and anti-aging products and treatments that make claims regarding stem cell technology are increasingly popular, despite a lack of evidence for safety and efficacy of such products.

Objectives

This study explores how stem cell–based products and services are portrayed to the public through online sources, in order to gain insight into the key messages available to consumers.

Methods

A content analysis of 100 web pages was conducted to examine the portrayals of stem cell–based cosmetic and anti-aging products and treatments. A qualitative discourse analysis of one web page further examined how language contributes to the portrayals of these products and treatments to public audiences.

Results

The majority of web pages portrayed stem cell–based products as ready for public use. Very few web pages substantiated claims with scientific evidence, and even fewer mentioned any risks or limitations associated with stem cell science. The discourse analysis revealed that the framing and use of metaphor obscures the certainty of the efficacy of and length of time for stem cell–based anti-aging technology to be publicly available.

Conclusions

This study highlights the need to educate patients and the public on the current limits of stem cell applications in this context. In addition, generating scientific evidence for stem cell–based anti-aging and aesthetic applications is needed for optimizing benefits and minimizing adverse effects for the public. Having more evidence on efficacy and risks will help to protect patients who are eagerly seeking out these treatments.