Reproductive isolating barriers between colour-differentiated populations of an African annual killifish, Nothobranchius korthausae (Cyprinodontiformes)

Abstract

Allopatric populations separated by vicariance events are expected to evolve reproductive isolating mechanisms as a result of disparate selection pressures and genetic drift. The appearance of reproductive isolating mechanisms may vary across taxa with differences in the opportunity for mate choice, and may be asymmetrical. In addition, premating barriers may be affected by individual mating experience. We used choice and no-choice experiments to investigate reproductive isolation between two allopatric (island and mainland) and colour-differentiated populations of an African annual fish, Nothobranchius korthausae. Assortative mating under experimental conditions was limited and asymmetrical. Preference for sympatric males was only expressed in nonvirgin females from one population. Virgin fish from both populations mated indiscriminately. No difference in the number of eggs laid, fertilization rate and hatching success was detected in no-choice experiments. All mating combinations produced viable offspring and no postmating barriers were detected in terms of the performance and fertility of F1 hybrids. Overall, we found little evidence for significant reproductive isolation, which is in contrast with the related killifish taxa in which assortative mating can be strong, even among allopatric populations with no colour differentiation.

allopatric divergence, assortative mating, colour polymorphism, mating experience, premating barriers, reproductive isolation