Abstract

An explanation is developed for the adaptive significance of the forms characteristic of the dry season and wet season adult generations of some tropical butterflies. The divergent phenotypes are accounted for as adaptive responses to a shift in the optimum balance between dependence on the alternative (but interdependent) strategies of active anti-predator devices and of crypsis. The seasonal polyphenisms exhibited by the satyrines Melanitis leda (Fabricius) and Orsotrioena medus (Fabricius) and the nymphalid Junonia almana (Linné) are examined in detail. The wet season forms show prominent marginal eyespot patterns which are displayed at rest and function principally in the deflection of attacks by vertebrate predators. In contrast, the dry season forms show very small or no spots and are wholly cryptic. Wet season butterflies are more active in general than those in the dry season when aestivation behaviour is often observed. The alternative phenotypes represent responses to the differences in behaviour, environment and nature of predation. Reproductive success is optimized in each season by an interaction of phenotype and behaviour. The hypothesis must be tested in detail by an investigation of the behavioural ecology and population biology of particular species. It is argued that these seasonal polyphenisms provide examples of adaptations to a repeating pattern of changing environments where the mode of selection is, in broad terms, understood.

REFERENCES

BENGTSON
,
S. A.
1981
.
Does bird predation influence the spot-number variation in Maniola jurtina (Lepidoptera)
Biological Journal of the Linnean Society
 ,
15
,
23
27
.
BLEST
,
A. D.
1957
.
The function of eyespot patterns in the Lepidoptera
.
Behaviour
 ,
11
,
209
256
.
BLOWERS
,
M. D.
&
WIERNASZ
,
D. C.
1979
.
Avian predation on the palatable butterfly, Cercyonis pegala (Satyridae)
.
Ecological Entomology
 ,
4
,
205
209
.
BRAKEFIELD
,
P. M.
1979
.
An experimental study of the maintenance of variation in spot pattern in Maniola jurtina
.
Unpublished Ph.D. Thesis
 , University of Liverpool.
BRAKEFIELD
,
P. M.
1982
.
Ecological studies on the butterfly Maniola jurtina in Britain. I. Adult behaviour, microdistribution and dispersal
.
Journal of Animal Ecology
 ,
51
,
713
726
.
BRAKEFIELD
,
P. M.
1984
.
The ecological genetics of quantitative characters in Maniola jurtina and other butterflies Symposia of the Royal Entomological Society
,
11
,
The Biology of Butterflies
 ,
167
190
.
DOUGLAS
,
M. M.
&
GRULA
,
J. W.
1978
.
Thermoregulatory adaptations allowing ecological range expansion by the pierid butterfly Nathalis iole Boisduvai
.
Evolution
 ,
32
,
776
783
.
EDMUNDS
,
M.
1974
.
Defense in Animals
 .
London
:
Longman
.
EDWARDS
,
E. D.
1973
.
Delayed ovarian development and aestivation in adult females of Heteronympha merope merope (Lepidoptera: Satyrinae)
.
Journal of the Australian Entomological Society
 ,
12
,
92
98
.
ENDLER
,
J. A.
1978
.
A predator's view of animal color patterns
.
Evolutionary Biology
 ,
11
,
319
364
.
ISHII
,
M.
&
HIDAKA
,
T.
1979
.
Seasonal polymorphism of the adult rice-plant skipper, Parnara guttata guttata (Lepidoptera: Hesperiidae) and its control
.
Applied Entomology and Zoology
 ,
14
,
173
184
.
KIRK
,
W. D. J.
1982
.
Variation of forewing spot number in the mineus-group of Mycalesis (HBN.) (Lepidoptera, Satyridae) in S.E. Asia
.
The Malayan Nature Journal
 ,
35
,
229
236
.
LARSEN
,
T. B.
1974
.
Butterflies of Lebanon
 .
Beirut
:
National Council for Scientific Research
.
LARSEN
,
T. B.
1982
.
Heavy predation by birds or lizards of Hipparchia parisatis (Kollar) (Lepidoptera: Satyridae) in Oman
.
Entomologist's Gazette
 ,
33
,
5
7
.
LARSEN
,
T. B.
1984
.
The Butterflies of the Arabian Peninsula
 .
London
:
Stacey International
.
LARSEN
,
T. B.
&
LARSEN
,
K.
1980
.
Butterflies of Oman
 .
Edinburgh
:
Bartholomew Books
.
McLEOD
,
L.
1968
.
Controlled environment experiments with Precis octavia Cram. (Nymphalidae)
.
Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera
 ,
7
,
1
18
.
MARSH
,
W.
&
ROTHSCHILD
,
M.
1974
.
Aposematic and cryptic Lepidoptera tested on the Mouse
.
Journal of Zoology, London
 ,
174
,
89
122
.
MASETTI
,
M.
&
SCALI
,
V.
1972
.
Ecological adjustments of the reproductive biology in Maniola jurtina from Tuscany
.
Accademia Nazionale Dei Lincei
 ,
53
,
460
468
.
NIJHOUT
,
H. F.
1978
.
Wing pattern formation in the Lepidoptera: A model
.
The Journal of Experimental Zoology
 ,
206
,
119
136
.
NIJHOUT
,
H. F.
1980
.
Pattern formation on Lepidoptera wings: Determination of an eyespot
.
Developmental Biology
 ,
80
,
267
274
.
OWEN
,
D. F.
1971
.
Tropical Butterflies
 .
Oxford
:
Clarendon Press
.
OWEN
,
D. F.
1980
.
Camouflage and mimicry
 .
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
.
ROBBINS
,
R. K.
1980
.
The Lycaenid “false head” hypothesis: Historical review and quantitative analysis
.
Journal of the Lepidopterists' Society
 ,
34
,
194
208
.
ROLAND
,
J.
1982
.
Melanism and diel activity of alpine Colias (Lepidoptera: Pieridae)
.
Oecologia
 ,
53
,
214
221
.
SAKAI
,
T.
&
MASAKI
,
S.
1965
.
Photoperiod as a factor causing seasonal forms in Lycaena phlaeas daimio Seitz
.
Konlju (Tokyo)
 ,
33
,
275
283
.
SCALI
,
V.
1971
.
Imaginal diapause and gonadal maturation of Maniola jurtina (Lepidoptera: Satyridae) from Tuscany
.
Journal of Animal Ecology
 ,
40
,
435
440
.
SCHWANWITSCH
,
B.
1948
.
Evolution of the wing-pattern in palaearctic Satyridae. IV. Polymorphic radiation and parallelism
.
Acta Zoologica
 ,
29
,
1
61
.
SHAPIRO
,
A. M.
1976
.
Seasonal polyphenism
.
Evolutionary Biology
 ,
9
,
259
333
.
SHAPIRO
,
A. M.
1980
.
Convergence in pierine polyphenisms (Lepidoptera)
.
Journal of Natural History
 ,
14
,
781
802
.
SWANEPOEL
,
D. A.
1953
.
Butterflies of South Africa
 .
CapeTown
:
Maskew Miller
.
TRIMEN
,
R.
1887
.
South African Butterflies; Nymphalinae
 . London ;
Trubner and Co.
WATT
,
W. B.
1969
.
Adaptive significance of pigment polymorphisms in Colias butterflies. II. Thermoregulation and photoperiodically controlled melanin variation in Colias eurytheme
.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, U.S.
 ,
63
,
767
774
.
WYNTHER-BLYTH
,
M. A.
1957
.
Butterflies of the Indian Region
 .
Bombay
:
Bombay Natural History Society
.
YOUNG
,
A. M.
1980
.
The interaction of predators and “eyespot butterflies” feeding on rotting fruits and soupy fungi in tropical forests: Variations on a theme developed by the Muyshondts and Arthur M. Shapiro
.
The Entomologist's Record
 ,
90
,
63
69
.