Skip to Main Content

The Turnout Myth: Voting Rates and Partisan Outcomes in American National Elections

Online ISBN:
9780190089498
Print ISBN:
9780190089450
Publisher:
Oxford University Press
Book

The Turnout Myth: Voting Rates and Partisan Outcomes in American National Elections

Daron Shaw,
Daron Shaw
Professor of Political Science, University of Texas
Find on
John Petrocik
John Petrocik
Professor of Political Science, University of Missouri
Find on
Published online:
19 December 2019
Published in print:
16 April 2020
Online ISBN:
9780190089498
Print ISBN:
9780190089450
Publisher:
Oxford University Press

Abstract

This book refutes the widely held convention that high turnout in national elections advantages Democratic candidates while low turnout helps Republicans. It examines over fifty years of presidential, gubernatorial, Senate, and House election data to show there is no consistent partisan effect associated with turnout. The overall relationship between the partisan vote and turnout for these offices is uncorrelated. Most significant, there is no observable party bias to turnout when each office or seat is examined through time. In some states, across the decades, gubernatorial and senatorial contests show a pro-Democratic bias to turnout; in others an increase in turnout helps Republicans. The pattern repeats for House elections during the 1970s, 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and through the 2010s. The analysis demonstrates that, within the range that turnout varies in American elections, it is the participation and abstention of easily influenced, less engaged citizens—peripheral voters—that move the outcome between the parties. These voters are the most influenced when the short-term forces of the election—differential candidate appeal, issues, scandals, and so forth—help the parties. Since these influences advantage Republicans as often as Democrats, the oscillation in turnout that coincides with pro-GOP and pro-Democratic forces leaves turnout rates inconsequential overall. The connections between short-term forces and the election cycle dominate the inconsistent partisan effects of turnout.

Contents
Close
This Feature Is Available To Subscribers Only

Sign In or Create an Account

Close

This PDF is available to Subscribers Only

View Article Abstract & Purchase Options

For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription.

Close