
Contents
Bibliography
-
Published:December 2022
Cite
Notes on Methodology
For qualitative media content analysis, I consulted two Japanese broadsheet national newspapers Yomiuri Shimbun and Asahi Shimbun as my main primary sources for newspaper reports. There were several advantages in the selection of these two papers. Firstly, the Yomiuri and the Asahi are the best-selling (7.4 million copies per day in 2021) and second-best selling (4.9 million per day in 2021) newspapers in the country respectively (Yomiuri Shimbun 2021). They are therefore indicative of the general tone and direction of national media discourse. Secondly, the Yomiuri is a leading conservative paper, while the Asahi is known for its progressive agenda: comparing the two enabled me to see how different political leanings shaped reactions to the Aum Affair as expressed through their editorials and news reports. Thirdly, on a more practical note, both papers were accessible through online digital archives, making archival work in the UK considerably easier than it would have been otherwise.
As additional sources, I have included articles from the national newspapers Mainichi Shimbun and Sankei Shimbun, and some contemporary affairs magazines such as AERA and Bungei Shunjū, limiting the analysis to editorials in the first month after the Tokyo attack (March to April 1995). Both Mainichi and Sankei are widely read national newspapers: Mainichi has a daily circulation of 2.1 million copies, while Sankei has 1.2 million daily readers as of 2021 (Yomiuri Shimbun 2021). They have contrasting political stances, with the Mainichi widely regarded as a centrist and liberal newspaper, while the Sankei is the most right-wing of major national papers. Due to time constraints during my fieldwork, these newspapers comprise a small sample of the overall data, but nonetheless provide useful comparisons to the Yomiuri and the Asahi.
For each newspaper, I searched for articles containing key words in Japanese such as ‘Aum Shinrikyō’, ‘Sarin’, ‘Matsumoto Sarin Incident’ and ‘Subway Sarin Incident’. Given the massive number of media reports on the Aum Affair, I narrowed down the date range of search for each topic to recover the most relevant articles. For initial reports on the Matsumoto Sarin Incident (which occurred on 27 June 1994) and Subway Sarin Incident (which occurred on 20 March 1995), I covered the period between June 1994 and December 1995. I then looked at commemorative media coverage of the Matsumoto Sarin Incident in June between 1996 and 2015, and in March between 1996 and 2015 for the Tokyo Subway Sarin Incident. This enabled an extensive but still manageable collection of articles. Many of the articles that I included were general news reports from the ‘society’ (shakai) section, editorials and opinion columns, letters to the editor, and special reports. All the articles were written in Japanese, and all translations are my own.
A unique aspect of Japanese newspapers is that different regional offices have a degree of editorial independence. This means that there is some variation in how regional editions print stories. For instance, cover stories may have different lengths depending on the relevance to the region and may have different layouts. There are also stories printed only in regional editions. In principle, I have privileged articles printed in ‘national’ editions. However, where there have been detailed reports on Aum in region-only editions, I have chosen to include them to demonstrate possible regional variations in media coverage of the Aum Affair.
One of the drawbacks of relying on online archives was the removal of visual data in the archival format. Visual information – such as photographs, cartoons, tables and figures, and diagrams – is a key component of print media, and especially so for newspapers, which rely on eye-catching headlines and photographs as part of their storytelling. Due to the storage format of archived articles as well as copyright issues, visual data presented in newspapers had to be omitted from the analysis, and where possible, I have considered other forms of visual media, such as magazines, television, and film.
Primary Sources
Interviews
Date . | Name (surname/first name) . | Title/Occupation . |
---|---|---|
18 March 2015 | Shimada Hiromi | Independent scholar, Religious Studies |
25 March 2015 | Inoue Nobutaka | Academic, Religious Studies |
27 March 2015 | Nagaoka Hiroyuki | Anti-Aum activist, survivor of an assassination attempt by Aum |
30 March 2015 | Noda Naruhito | Former leader of Aleph |
31 March 2015 | Ōta Toshihiro | Academic, Religious Studies |
6 April 2015 | Takahashi Shizue | Spokesperson for Subway Sarin Incident Victims’ Society |
10 April 2015 | Kōno Yoshiyuki | Survivor and widower of Matsumoto Sarin Incident |
8 July 2016 | Aoki Yumiko | Freelance book editor |
20 July 2016 | Mori Tatsuya | Film director; writer |
24 July 2016 | Jōyū Fumihiro | Leader, Hikari no Wa. Formerly leader of Aleph |
29 July 2016 | Anonymous | Former member of Aum/Aleph |
29 July 2016 | Hirosue Akitoshi | PR spokesperson for Hikari no Wa |
Date . | Name (surname/first name) . | Title/Occupation . |
---|---|---|
18 March 2015 | Shimada Hiromi | Independent scholar, Religious Studies |
25 March 2015 | Inoue Nobutaka | Academic, Religious Studies |
27 March 2015 | Nagaoka Hiroyuki | Anti-Aum activist, survivor of an assassination attempt by Aum |
30 March 2015 | Noda Naruhito | Former leader of Aleph |
31 March 2015 | Ōta Toshihiro | Academic, Religious Studies |
6 April 2015 | Takahashi Shizue | Spokesperson for Subway Sarin Incident Victims’ Society |
10 April 2015 | Kōno Yoshiyuki | Survivor and widower of Matsumoto Sarin Incident |
8 July 2016 | Aoki Yumiko | Freelance book editor |
20 July 2016 | Mori Tatsuya | Film director; writer |
24 July 2016 | Jōyū Fumihiro | Leader, Hikari no Wa. Formerly leader of Aleph |
29 July 2016 | Anonymous | Former member of Aum/Aleph |
29 July 2016 | Hirosue Akitoshi | PR spokesperson for Hikari no Wa |
Television programmes
Broadcaster . | Title . | Original Air Date . |
---|---|---|
Fuji Terebi | Tsumayo! Matsumoto sarin jiken hannin to yobarete … Kazoku o mamorinuita 15 nen | 26 June 2009 |
Fuji Terebi | Chikatetsu sarin jiken 15 nen me no tatakai | 20 March 2010 |
Fuji Terebi | Gekido! Seiki no daijiken Oumu Shinrikyō to tatakatta ‘kazoku no zenkiroku’ | 20 March 2015 |
NHK | Ningen Dokyumento. Tsuma Shizue san no haru: Chikatetsu sarin jiken izoku no hibi | 15 April 2005 |
NHK | Mikaiketsu jiken File No.2 Oumu Shinrikyō Jiken | 26, 27 May 2012 |
TV Tokyo | Hōdō sukūpu purojekuto Oumu wa imamo ikiteiru: sōryoku tsuiseki! Chikatetsu sarin jiken 20 nen | 7 March 2015 |
Yomiuri Terebi | NNN Dokyumento Ashiato Matsumoto sarin jiken 20 nen | 30 June 2014 |
Broadcaster . | Title . | Original Air Date . |
---|---|---|
Fuji Terebi | Tsumayo! Matsumoto sarin jiken hannin to yobarete … Kazoku o mamorinuita 15 nen | 26 June 2009 |
Fuji Terebi | Chikatetsu sarin jiken 15 nen me no tatakai | 20 March 2010 |
Fuji Terebi | Gekido! Seiki no daijiken Oumu Shinrikyō to tatakatta ‘kazoku no zenkiroku’ | 20 March 2015 |
NHK | Ningen Dokyumento. Tsuma Shizue san no haru: Chikatetsu sarin jiken izoku no hibi | 15 April 2005 |
NHK | Mikaiketsu jiken File No.2 Oumu Shinrikyō Jiken | 26, 27 May 2012 |
TV Tokyo | Hōdō sukūpu purojekuto Oumu wa imamo ikiteiru: sōryoku tsuiseki! Chikatetsu sarin jiken 20 nen | 7 March 2015 |
Yomiuri Terebi | NNN Dokyumento Ashiato Matsumoto sarin jiken 20 nen | 30 June 2014 |
Films
Laws
1995.
1995.
1998.
1999.
1999.
2004.
2008.
Publications by Aum Shinrikyō/Aleph
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara, S.
Asahara S.
Jōyū, F.
Jōyū, F.
Jōyū, F.
Secondary sources
Alexander, Jeffrey C.
Alexander, Jeffrey C.
Alexander, Jeffrey C.
Alexander, Jeffrey C.
Alexander, Jeffrey C., and Elizabeth Butler Breese.
Altglas, Véronique.
Anthony, Dick, and Thomas Robbins.
Aoki, Yumiko, ed.
Aonuma, Yōichirō.
Asahara Kōsoshin Bengonin, ed.
Austin, John L.
Baert, Patrick.
Baert, Patrick.
Baert, Patrick, and Alan Shipman.
Baffelli, Erica.
Baffelli, Erica.
Baffelli, Erica.
Baffelli, Erica, and Ian Reader.
Baffelli, Erica, and Ian Reader.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M.
Bakhtin, Mikhail M., Pavel N. Medvedev, and V. N. Voloshinov.
Barker, Eileen.
Barker, Eileen.
Bartmanski, Dominik, and Ron Eyerman.
Benedict, Ruth.
Billig, Michael.
Bromley, David G.
Buruma, Ian.
Caruth, Cathy.
CCCS Popular Memory Group.
Chikatestu Sarin Jiken Higaisha no Kai.
Chikatestu Sarin Jiken Higaisha no Kai.
Chikatestu Sarin Jiken Higaisha no Kai.
Cohen, Stanley.
Connerton, Paul.
Conway, Brian.
Conway, Brian.
Cowan, Douglas E.
Dorman, Benjamin. 2001. “Aum Shinrikyo”. Religion in the News. Retrieved 25 February 2017 (www.trincoll.edu/depts/csrpl/RINVol4No1/aum_shinrikyo.htm).
Dorman, Benjamin.
Dorman, Benjamin.
Dower, John W.
Ducharme, Lori J., and Gary Alan Fine.
Durkheim, Émile.
Edelman, Bryan, and James T. Richardson.
Egawa, Shōko.
Egawa, Shōko.
Erikson, Kai.
Erll, Astrid.
Eyerman, Ron.
Eyerman, Ron.
Eyerman, Ron.
Eyerman, Ron.
Eyerman, Ron.
Fine, Gary Alan.
Freud, Sigmund.
Friedlander, Saul.
Fromm, Erich.
Fujita, Shōichi.
Fujiwara, Shinya.
Furihata, Ken’ichi.
Gardner, Richard A.
Gardner, Richard A.
Gardner, Richard A.
Gardner, Richard A.
Gardner, Richard A.
Geilhorn, Barbara, and Kristina Iwata-Weickgenannt, eds.
Giesen, Bernhard.
Hacking, Ian. 2000. “
Halbwachs, Maurice.
Hardacre, Helen.
Hashimoto, Akiko.
Hassan, Steven.
Hayakawa, Kiyohide, and Kunimitsu Kawamura.
Hayashi, Ikuo.
Hikari no Wa Gaibu Kansa Iinkai.
Hirano, Naoko, and Hotaka Tsukada.
Hirose, Ken’ichi.
Hughes, Christopher W.
Human Rights Without Frontiers.
Igarashi, Yoshikuni.
Inoue, Madoka.
Inoue, Nobutaka.
Inoue, Nobutaka.
Inoue, Nobutaka, Michio Takeda, and Kiyoyasu Kitabatake.
Irons, Edward A.
Ishii, Kenji.
Jōyū, Fumihiro.
Jōyū, Fumihiro.
Jōyū, Fumihiro.
Jōyū, Fumihiro.
Jōyū, Fumihiro, Kunio Suzuki, and Hiroyuki Jo.
Jōyū, Fumihiro, and Sōichirō Tahara.
Kadota, Ryusho.
Kanariya no kai, ed.
Kavitha, Rao, and Mutsuko Murakami. 1997. “
Kim, Mikyoung, and Barry Schwartz, eds.
Kisala, Robert J.
Klein, Axel.
Koike, Yasushi.
Komiya, Hiromi.
Kōno, Yoshiyuki.
Kōno, Yoshiyuki.
Kōno, Yoshiyuki.
Kumai, Kei.
Kurasawa, Fuyuki.
LaCapra, Dominick.
Lewis, James R., ed.
Lewis, James R.
Lifton, Robert Jay.
Manne, Robert.
Matsubara, Hiroshi. 2002. “
Matsumoto, Rika.
Matsumoto, Satoka.
McLaughlin, Levi.
McLuhan, Marshall.
Misztal, Barbara.
Miyadai, Shinji.
Mori, Tatsuya.
Mori, Tatsuya.
Mori, Tatsuya, and Takaharu Yasuoka.
Mullins, Mark.
Mullins, Mark, and Koichi Nakano.
Murakami, Haruki.
Murakami, Haruki.
Murakami, Haruki.
Nagaoka, Eiko. 2009. “Oumu Shinrikyō Ni Kakawatte”. Retrieved 14 October 2020 (http://ww4.tiki.ne.jp/~enkoji/nagaoka.htm).
National Police Agency.
Nishi, Kumiko.
NHK Supesharu Shuzaihan.
Noda, Naruhito.
Noda, Naruhito.
Nora, Pierre.
Olick, Jeffrey K.
Olick, Jeffrey K.
Olick, Jeffrey K.
Olick, Jeffrey K., Vered Vinitzky-Seroussi, and Daniel Levy, eds.
Ōta, Toshihiro.
Palmer, Susan.
Pendleton, Mark.
Pendleton, Mark.
Pendleton, Mark.
Pendleton, Mark.
Public Security Intelligence Agency.
Public Security Intelligence Agency.
Public Security Intelligence Agency.
Public Security Intelligence Agency.
Qurashi, Fahid. (
Radstone, Susannah.
Reader, Ian.
Reader, Ian.
Reader, Ian.
Reader, Ian.
Richardson, James T.
Richardson, James T., and Massimo Introvigne.
RIRC. 2018. “
Rojas-Perez, Isaias.
Rothberg, Michael.
Saaler, Sven.
Said, Edward W.
Said, Edward W.
Saito, Hiro.
Saito, Hiro.
Sakurai, Yoshihide.
Sanpo, Ketsun, and Shin’ichi Nakazawa.
Schwartz, Barry.
Schwartz, Barry, and Howard Schuman.
Searle, John R.
Seaton, Philip A.
Sennett, Richard.
Seraphim, Franziska.
Shimada, Hiromi.
Shimazono, Susumu.
Shimazono, Susumu.
Shimazono, Susumu.
Shupe, Anson, David Bromley, and Susan E. Darnell.
Simko, Christine.
Sims, Calvin. 2000. “
Smelser, Neil J.
Smelser, Neil J.
Smith, Andrea L.
Takahashi, Hidetoshi.
Takahashi, Shizue.
Takayama, Fumihiko.
Takimoto, Tarō, and Tatsuya Nagaoka.
Taylor, Diana.
Thomas, Jolyon Baraka.
Tsukada, Hotaka.
Turner, Victor W.
Turner, Victor W.
Umehara, Takeshi, and Tetsuo Yamaori.
Ushiyama, Rin.
Ushiyama, Rin.
Ushiyama, Rin.
Ushiyama, Rin, and Patrick Baert.
Utsunomiya Kenji, Nakamura Yūji, and Matsui Yutaka.
Van Gennep, Arnold.
Vinitzky-Seroussi, Vered.
Voloshinov, Valentin N.
Wagner-Pacifici, Robin.
Wagner-Pacifici, Robin, and Barry Schwartz.
Wallis, Roy.
Watanabe, Manabu.
Watanabe, Manabu.
Watanabe, Manabu.
Weine, Stevan.
Wessinger, Catherine.
Wessinger, Catherine.
Wiesel, Elie.
Winter, Franz.
Winter, Jay.
Winter, Jay.
Yamada, Marc.
Yang, Fenggang.
Yomiuri Shimbun.
Yoneyama, Lisa.
Zerubavel, Eviatar.
Month: | Total Views: |
---|---|
February 2023 | 2 |
March 2023 | 4 |
April 2023 | 1 |
May 2023 | 2 |
August 2023 | 1 |
October 2023 | 2 |
January 2024 | 9 |
June 2024 | 1 |
July 2024 | 1 |
August 2024 | 1 |