Abstract

Measles remains one of the most important causes of child morbidity and mortality worldwide with the greatest burden in the youngest children. Most acute measles deaths are owing to secondary infections that result from a poorly understood measles-induced suppression of immune responses. Young children are also vulnerable to late development of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis, a progressive, uniformly fatal neurologic disease caused by persistent measles virus (MeV) infection. During acute infection, the rash marks the appearance of the adaptive immune response and CD8+ T cell-mediated clearance of infectious virus. However, after clearance of infectious virus, MeV RNA persists and can be detected in blood, respiratory secretions, urine, and lymphoid tissue for many weeks to months. This prolonged period of virus clearance may help to explain measles immunosuppression and the development of lifelong immunity to re-infection, as well as occasional infection of the nervous system. Once MeV infects neurons, the virus can spread trans-synaptically and the envelope proteins needed to form infectious virus are unnecessary, accumulate mutations, and can establish persistent infection. Identification of the immune mechanisms required for the clearance of MeV RNA from multiple sites will enlighten our understanding of the development of disease owing to persistent infection.

Introduction

Measles remains one of the most important causes of child morbidity and mortality worldwide with the greatest burden in the youngest children (Moss & Griffin, ; Nandy et al., ; Wolfson et al., ). Measles is unique for childhood rash diseases, in that it is associated with substantial mortality with a case fatality rate of 5–10% in Africa (Nandy et al., ; Grais et al., ) and up to 25% in refugee camps and virgin populations (Moss, ; Shanks et al., ). Mortality is highest in girls, and most acute measles deaths are owing to secondary infections that result from a poorly understood measles-induced suppression of immune responses (Beckford et al., ; Tamashiro et al., ; Garenne, ; Shanks et al., ). In addition to the risks of acute infection, children, particularly boys, under the age of 2 years are also vulnerable to the development of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE), a progressive, uniformly fatal neurologic disease associated with persistent measles virus (MeV) infection of the nervous system. SSPE has a long latent period and presents many years after the original MeV infection (Freeman et al., ; Cattaneo et al., ; Bellini et al., ).

A safe and efficacious live-attenuated virus vaccine is available, and recent strides have been made toward global measles control. However, logistical and financial difficulties in sustaining the current vaccination strategies in developing countries have led the World Health Organization to forecast an increase in the number of measles cases and deaths (Centers for Disease Control, ). Furthermore, complacency and concerns about safety, along with philosophical and religious objections to vaccination, have resulted in failure to control measles in many industrialized nations (Muscat et al., ; Richard & Masserey Spicher, ).

MeV and virus replication

MeV is a negative-sense RNA virus with a nonsegmented genome (Fig. 0001b) and a lipid envelope that belongs to the morbillivirus genus of the family Paramyxoviridae. The 16 kb genome encodes eight proteins and most likely evolved from rinderpest virus, a recently eradicated disease of cattle (Barrett, ; Furuse et al., ; Horzinek, ). Six proteins are found in the virion (Fig. 0001a). The envelope has surface projections composed of the viral hemagglutinin (H) and fusion (F) glycoproteins with the matrix (M) protein lining the interior. The helical nucleocapsid is formed from the genomic RNA wrapped with the nucleocapsid (N) protein and is packed within the envelope in the form of a symmetrical coil with the phosphoprotein (P) and large polymerase (L) proteins attached. There are two nonstructural proteins, C and V, encoded within the P gene that regulates the cellular response to infection and modulates interferon (IFN) signaling (Bellini et al., ; Cattaneo et al., ). C is translated from an alternative start site by leaky scanning to produce a basic protein of 186 amino acids. V has the same N-terminus (231 amino acids) as P, but insertion of an additional guanine by RNA editing alters the reading frame to produce a unique 68 amino acid cysteine-rich zinc-binding C-terminal domain that is highly conserved among paramyxoviruses (Cattaneo et al., b; Liston & Briedis, ).

Schematic diagrams of the measles virion (a), genome (b), and intracellular replication cycle (c). (a) The enveloped virion has six proteins: two surface glycoproteins, hemagglutinin (H), and fusion (F); a matrix (M) protein; a nucleocapsid (N) protein that surrounds the negative-sense RNA and two replicase proteins, the phosphoprotein (P) and large (L) polymerase protein. (b) The P gene also encodes two host cell response regulatory proteins, V and C. (c) The H protein interacts with one of several MeV receptors resulting in F-mediated fusion with the plasma membrane. Replication occurs in the cytoplasm and assembled virions bud from the plasma membrane (Moss & Griffin, ).
Figure 1

Schematic diagrams of the measles virion (a), genome (b), and intracellular replication cycle (c). (a) The enveloped virion has six proteins: two surface glycoproteins, hemagglutinin (H), and fusion (F); a matrix (M) protein; a nucleocapsid (N) protein that surrounds the negative-sense RNA and two replicase proteins, the phosphoprotein (P) and large (L) polymerase protein. (b) The P gene also encodes two host cell response regulatory proteins, V and C. (c) The H protein interacts with one of several MeV receptors resulting in F-mediated fusion with the plasma membrane. Replication occurs in the cytoplasm and assembled virions bud from the plasma membrane (Moss & Griffin, ).

H interacts with the virus receptor for attachment and F interacts with H and with the same or an additional cellular protein for fusion and entry (Fig. 0001c). Three receptors have been identified: membrane cofactor protein or CD46 (Dorig et al., ; Naniche et al., ), signaling lymphocyte activation molecule (SLAM) or CD150 (Tatsuo et al., ), and poliovirus receptor-related 4 (PVRL4) or nectin 4 (Muhlebach et al., ; Noyce et al., ). CD46 is a widely distributed human complement regulatory protein expressed on all nucleated cells (Riley-Vargas et al., ). It acts as a cofactor for the proteolytic inactivation of C3b/C4b by factor I (Riley-Vargas et al., ), but also induces proliferation and differentiation of regulatory T cells (Kemper et al., ). SLAM is a costimulatory molecule expressed on activated cells of the immune system (Sidorenko & Clark, ). The cytoplasmic domain has an immunoreceptor tyrosine-based switch motif that binds small SH-2 domain adaptor proteins important for cell signaling (Yanagi et al., ; Ohno et al., ). Nectin-4 is an adherens junction protein of the immunoglobulin superfamily expressed on epithelial cells (Sinn et al., ; Shirogane et al., ). The receptor-binding regions on H are all found on the lateral surface of the head structure and are contiguous or overlapping (Santiago et al., , ; Schneider et al., ; Masse et al., ; Vongpunsawad et al., ; Colf et al., ; Hashiguchi et al., , ). Both vaccine and wild-type strains of MeV can use SLAM as a receptor, but wild-type strains do not use CD46 efficiently (Ono et al., ; Erlenhofer et al., ; Yanagi et al., ). Differences in receptor usage may involve interactions with F as well as H (Kouomou & Wild, ; Takeuchi et al., ).

MeV probably uses additional receptors. In acute infections, endothelial cells, as well as epithelial and immune system cells, are infected (Esolen et al., ; Oldstone et al., ; Andres et al., ; Takeuchi et al., ), and in persistent infections, neurons and glial cells are important targets for infection (McQuaid & Cosby, ; Shingai et al., ). The vaccine virus was attenuated by growth in chicken cells.

H and F cooperate to induce fusion of the viral envelope and cellular plasma membrane for entry. Infected cells expressing the viral glycoproteins at the cell surface can also fuse with uninfected cells to produce multinucleated giant cells followed by cell death. However, not all types of infected cells fuse to form syncytia. In vivo, giant cells are observed in the lung, skin, and lymphatic tissue, but not the central nervous system (CNS). Cellular protein synthesis is relatively unaffected by MeV infection, but specific cellular proteins (e.g. cell surface receptors) and functional responses (e.g. signal transduction and expression of transcription factors) may be altered in a cell-type-specific manner (Bazarsky et al., ; Fishman et al., ; Indoh et al., ).

MeV replication is interferon (IFN)-sensitive (Leopardi et al., ; Naniche et al., ) and some IFN-stimulated proteins (e.g. MxA, ADAR1) inhibit MeV replication in a cell-type-specific manner (Schnorr et al., ; Schneider-Schaulies et al., ; Ward et al., ). However, MeV effectively inhibits both the induction of IFN synthesis and IFN signaling in infected cells, and this property may play an important role in the ability of MeV to establish persistent infection. The C-terminal domain of the V protein prevents the induction of type I IFN synthesis both through the toll-like receptor (TLR)/MyD88 and RNA helicase pathways (He et al., ). V binds IKKα and inhibits TLR7/9-mediated phosphorylation of IRF7 in plasmacytoid dendritic cells (DCs) (Schlender et al., ; Pfaller & Conzelmann, ). V also binds MDA5, but not RIG-I, to prevent activation and induction of IFNβ synthesis through the RNA helicase pathway (Andrejeva et al., ; Childs et al., ). Strains of MeV differ in V sequence, and transient transfection studies indicate strain-dependent differences in function (Takaki et al., ).

If IFN is produced by infected cells, the common N-terminal domains of the P and V proteins inhibit IFN-induced STAT1 activation (Palosaari et al., ; Caignard et al., , ) and the C-terminal domain of V inhibits STAT2 activation (Ramachandran et al., ; Ramachandran & Horvath, ). However, the role of type I IFN in natural MeV infection is unclear. There is little evidence that IFNα/β is induced in vivo, and studies of IFN induction by MeV in vitro have been confounded by the frequent presence of defective interfering (DI) RNAs in virus stocks. DI RNAs are potent inducers of IFN, and one mechanism used to establish cell lines persistently infected with MeV (Rima et al., ; Yount et al., ).

Acute disease and tissue sites of replication

MeV is efficiently spread by the respiratory route and is highly infectious. Knowledge of measles pathogenesis comes from the study of naturally infected humans and experimentally infected macaques, animals that develop measles very similar to that of humans. Infection is initiated in the respiratory tract followed by rapid spread of virus to local lymphoid tissue and then to multiple other organs (Moench et al., ). Wild-type virus replicates efficiently in activated cells of the immune system that express SLAM (Yanagi et al., ; Condack et al., ; de Swart et al., ) and it is likely that immature pulmonary DCs or alveolar macrophages capture and transport MeV to regional lymph nodes where the immune response is initiated and the spread of infection is facilitated (Kaiserlian & Dubois, ; Schneider-Schaulies et al., ; Lemon et al., ).

There is a latent period of 10–14 days and a 2–3 day prodrome of fever, coryza, cough, and conjunctivitis followed by the appearance of a characteristic maculopapular rash (Lessler et al., ). Multiple organs (e.g. liver, lung, thymus, spleen, and skin) are infected, and target cells include epithelial cells, endothelial cells, B lymphocytes, T lymphocytes, monocyte/macrophages, and DCs (Moench et al., ; Plaza & Nuovo, ; de Swart et al., ), all cells that can be replaced if eliminated by the immune response during the process of virus clearance. Neurons and glial cells are not usually the targets of acute infection (Moench et al., ; McQuaid et al., ), but infected CNS endothelial cells have been observed in autopsy specimens (Esolen et al., ).

The onset of the rash coincides with the appearance of the adaptive immune response and initiation of clearance of infectious virus (Auwaerter et al., ). After the rash has faded, infectious virus can rarely be recovered and this correlates with decreased transmission of infection (Permar et al., ; Van Binnendijk et al., ; Pan et al., ). However, viral RNA persists for many weeks (Fig. 0002). Mechanisms of immune-mediated clearance of infectious virus and viral RNA from different types of cells may be distinct and occur at different rates.

Schematic diagram showing the time course of the clearance of infectious measles virus (blue) and viral RNA (dashed black line) from blood in relationship to the appearance and clearance of the rash (red box).
Figure 2

Schematic diagram showing the time course of the clearance of infectious measles virus (blue) and viral RNA (dashed black line) from blood in relationship to the appearance and clearance of the rash (red box).

Immune response and clearance

Replication of MeV usually causes death of cells in culture, but this is not necessarily the case in vivo. Persistent noncytopathic infection can be established in vitro, and this is most easily accomplished in neuronal cells, but persistent infections in lymphoid, epithelial, and glial cells have also been established (Miller & Carrigan, ; Rima & Duprex, ). Cellular factors that affect the ability of MeV to establish and maintain persistent infection include increased expression of heat-shock proteins, IFN-inducible proteins, and altered regulation of lipid metabolism (Miller & Carrigan, ; Schnorr et al., ; Rima & Duprex, ; Takahashi et al., ; Robinzon et al., ). Antisense RNA can be used to cure persistently infected cells (Koschel et al., ).

If the cell survives infection, virus clearance will require immune-mediated elimination of the cell or of intracellular virus. For many virus infections, factors produced by the innate immune response directly in response to virus infection (e.g. IFN-α/β, TNF, IL-1, IL-6, and IL-8) inhibit virus spread and set the stage for the adaptive immune response. However, the innate response to natural measles has not been well characterized. In vitro studies have shown that innate responses triggered by the interaction of MeV RNA or proteins with pathogen recognition receptors at the cell surface or in the cytoplasm to activate signaling pathways involving transcription factors NFκB and IRF 3 differ with the strain of virus, are cell-type-specific and are highly regulated by the viral P, C, and V proteins (Katayama et al., ; Helin et al., ; Bieback et al., ; Tenoever et al., ; Sato et al., ; Duhen et al., ; Schuhmann et al., ). MeV replication in vitro is sensitive to the inhibitory effects of IFNα/β. There is little evidence that type I IFN is produced in vivo during the acute phase of disease (Griffin et al., ; Leopardi et al., ; Schnorr et al., ; Tanabe et al., ; Yu et al., ), and this may be important for virulence as mutation of the V gene leads to virus attenuation (Devaux et al., ). IL-1 and IL-8 can be detected in plasma (Zilliox et al., ), but roles for these factors in control of MeV infection have not been identified.

Adaptive cellular immune responses are generally regarded as most important for the clearance of MeV. Children with agammaglobulinemia recover from infection, while those with defects in cellular immunity (e.g. HIV infection, congenital immune deficiency, transplant immune suppression, and chemotherapy) are prone to develop progressive infections of the lung (giant cell pneumonia) or CNS (inclusion body encephalitis) (Good & Zak, ; Enders et al., ; McQuaid et al., ; Albertyn et al., ). MeV-specific antibody and T cell responses appear coincident with the onset of the rash, and rash biopsies show infiltration of CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes in regions of epithelial cell infection (Fig. 0003).

The measles virus rash (a) is indicative of the immune response and results from the infiltration of leukocytes (b), including CD4+ (c) and CD8+ (d) T lymphocytes into sites of virus replication in the skin. Histological examination of a biopsy of a measles skin rash lesion shows (a) an accumulation of mononuclear cells (arrow) that have infiltrated an area of infected epithelial cells (hematoxylin and eosin stain). Immunoperoxidase staining (brown) of the biopsy for CD4+ (c) and CD8+ (d) T cells shows that many of the infiltrating mononuclear cells are T lymphocytes (Polack et al., ).
Figure 3

The measles virus rash (a) is indicative of the immune response and results from the infiltration of leukocytes (b), including CD4+ (c) and CD8+ (d) T lymphocytes into sites of virus replication in the skin. Histological examination of a biopsy of a measles skin rash lesion shows (a) an accumulation of mononuclear cells (arrow) that have infiltrated an area of infected epithelial cells (hematoxylin and eosin stain). Immunoperoxidase staining (brown) of the biopsy for CD4+ (c) and CD8+ (d) T cells shows that many of the infiltrating mononuclear cells are T lymphocytes (Polack et al., ).

Several lines of evidence suggest that CD8+ T lymphocytes are particularly important for control and clearance of infectious virus. MeV-specific cytotoxic T lymphocytes are found in the blood during the rash and CD4+ and CD8+ T cells infiltrate sites of virus replication (Myou et al., ; Jaye et al., ; Mongkolsapaya et al., ; Polack et al., ) (Fig. 0003). In monkeys, depletion of CD8+ T cells, but not B cells, at the time of infection results in a higher and more prolonged viremia (Permar et al., , ). In vitro, addition of CD8+, but not CD4+, T cells to MeV-infected B cells prevents spread to uninfected B cells (de Vries et al., ), and depletion of CD4+ T cells does not affect virus titers in the lungs of infected cotton rats (Pueschel et al., ). Both cytotoxicity and IFN-γ production have been implicated as effector mechanisms important for CD8+ T cell-mediated MeV clearance. The relative importance of each is likely to differ depending on the target cell and tissue (Finke et al., ; Patterson et al., ; Tishon et al., ; Stubblefield et al., ). For instance, IFN-γ-induced indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase is important for the control of MeV replication in epithelial, endothelial, and astroglial cells, but not in lymphoid or neuronal cells (Obojes et al., ).

In immunologically normal individuals, infectious virus cannot be recovered shortly after the rash fades (Fig. 0002). Clearance of infectious virus and resolution of the accompanying rash are associated with clinical recovery in most children. However, clearance of infectious virus is only part of the story. Our studies of Zambian children with natural measles and of rhesus macaques experimentally infected with a wild-type strain of MeV have shown that viral RNA persists in multiple locations long after infectious virus is no longer detectable (Fig. 0002) (Permar et al., ; Pan et al., ; Riddell et al., ). In prospective studies of children hospitalized with measles, MeV RNA was detected in 62% of children from at least one site (peripheral blood mononuclear cells [PBMCs], urine, or nasopharyngeal aspirates) at 1–2 months after discharge from the hospital and in 37% at 3–4 months after discharge (Permar et al., ; Riddell et al., ). These data indicate that clearance of MeV RNA after infection is a prolonged process.

Rhesus macaques infected with wild-type MeV have provided additional information on clearance because they can be followed closely from the time of infection. Infectious virus appears in the blood 4–7 days after infection and is cleared by 14–18 days. However, MeV RNA can be detected in PBMCs for 4–6 months (Pan et al., ). Clearance of virus and viral RNA from PBMCs occurs in phases. After an initial peak of RNA coinciding with recovery of infectious virus, there is a period of rapid decline in viral RNA, followed by a rebound and then a slow decline to undetectable levels. In animals studied for longer periods of time, viral RNA may reappear in PBMCs after apparent elimination suggesting persistence in other tissues (Pan et al., ). The length of time required for clearance from lymphoid and other tissues is not known.

Sequencing of RNA from late samples has identified no mutations in the variable regions of either the N or H genes (Riddell et al., ). These data suggest slow clearance as an explanation for the prolonged presence of MeV RNA after apparent recovery rather than mutation and escape from the immune response. A switch in the type of T cell response from type 1 to type 2 with the production of regulatory T cells and cytokines may play a role in slowing clearance of viral RNA (Ward et al., ; Moss et al., ; Yu et al., ). Prolonged presence of viral RNA is highly relevant to the development of persistent infection and could explain the immunologic abnormalities that persist after the rash fades as well as the development of lifelong immunity that characterizes the recovery from measles.

Persistent infection

The frequency of failure of virus clearance from various tissues is not known, but clinically significant disease in immunologically normal individuals has only been convincingly linked to persistent infection of the CNS. Approximately 1 in 10 000 children (boys > girls) will develop SSPE as a late complication of measles (Takasu et al., ; Bellini et al., ). Both host and virus factors are likely to play a role in establishing persistence. SSPE is most likely to develop if the primary MeV infection occurs before the age of 2 years when the immune system is immature and residual maternal antibody may still be present (Jabbour et al., ; Detels et al., ; Modlin et al., ; Halsey et al., ; Miller et al., ; Bellini et al., ). In developing countries with high birth rates, measles often occurs in young infants (Halsey et al., ; Moss et al., , ; Grais et al., ) and these countries appear to have a higher burden of SSPE (Saha et al., ; Takasu et al., ). This high burden is likely further exacerbated when there is a high prevalence of HIV infection because children of HIV-infected mothers are at increased risk to acquire measles at an early age (Embree et al., ; Moss et al., ), and animal models suggest that prior infection with an immunosuppressive virus increases the likelihood of persistent CNS infection (Oldstone et al., ).

Antibody to MeV may play a role in establishing persistent CNS infection either through the alteration of the induction of the primary immune response at the time of initial infection or through the modulation of infection once virus is in the nervous system (Fujinami & Oldstone, ; Rammohan et al., ; Endo et al., ). Passage of infected cells in the presence of antiviral antibody has been used to establish persistent infection in vitro (Rustigian, ). In small animals, treatment with antibody after intracerebral infection with MeV decreases acute disease, but increases the likelihood of persistent virus infection and subacute or chronic encephalitis (Wear & Rapp, ; Rammohan et al., ; Liebert et al., ). Cases of SSPE have been associated with passive transfer of immune globulin (Rammohan et al., ).

The average time to onset of SSPE after measles is 6–10 years, but ranges from 1 to 24 years (Modlin et al., ; Campbell et al., ). At the time that neurologic symptoms occur, neurons and glial cells contain nuclear and cytoplasmic MeV inclusion bodies and there is an extensive mononuclear inflammatory reaction in the CNS that includes CD4+ and CD8+ T cells, as well as monocytes and antibody-secreting B cells (Dawson, ; Herndon & Rubinstein, ; Brody et al., ; Esiri et al., ; Anlar et al., ). The antibody response to MeV is accentuated with significant production of MeV-specific antibody by plasma cells residing in the CNS (Burgoon et al., ). Thus, there is no evidence for a global defect in immune responses, but these immune responses are ineffective in clearing virus from the CNS.

Strains of MeV differ in ability to establish persistent infection in the same host cell in vitro (Fernandez-Munoz & Celma, ), but there is no clustering of SSPE cases to suggest that the wild-type virus causing the initial infection is different from the virus causing uncomplicated disease. Sequence analysis of viral RNA from various parts of the brain shows that the virus is clonal (Baczko et al., ), implying that virus may have entered the brain during the original acute infection, perhaps by infecting endothelial cells (Kirk et al., ; Esolen et al., ; Dittmar et al., ; Ludlow et al., ), was not cleared and gradually spread throughout the nervous system. Once within neurons, virus can spread from neuron-to-neuron without the release of infectious particles (Ehrengruber et al., ) and it has been suggested that the MeV F protein interacts at the synapse with the substance P receptor neurokinin-1 to mediate trans-synaptic spread (Makhortova et al., ).

However, the virus that is present in cell lines persistently infected with MeV and in the CNS at the time of the onset of clinically apparent SSPE differs substantially from the original wild-type virus. Although viral antigen and RNA are abundant in both inclusion body encephalitis of immune-compromised individuals and in SSPE, the virus is difficult, if not impossible, to culture from CNS tissue. In fact, some viruses thought to be SSPE viruses have been discovered to be laboratory contaminants (Rima et al., ). Variants associated with persistent infection in vitro often display properties indicative of impaired replication such as temperature-sensitivity (Rager-Zisman et al., ; Takahashi et al., ), accumulation of intranuclear and intracytoplasmic nucleocapsids, and decreased release of infectious virus (Robinzon et al., ). Some cell lines produce no infectious virus, and persistent infection is maintained by the passage of encapsidated viral RNA to daughter cells during cell division (Burnstein et al., ).

In SSPE, no virus is seen budding from the surface of infected cells. Nuclear inclusions are filled with ‘smooth’ nucleocapsids that lack associated RNA and P protein (Herndon & Rubinstein, ; Dubois-Dalcq et al., ). The cytoplasm contains ‘fuzzy’ nucleocapsids of N-encapsidated RNA decorated with P that extend into neuronal processes. Thus, virus can spread within the CNS by synaptic transmission of the ribonucleoprotein from cell to cell, a process that has been observed both in vivo and in vitro (Sawaishi et al., ; Duprex et al., ; Lawrence et al., ; Ehrengruber et al., ). Limited expression of viral proteins on the surface of persistently infected cells has led to the suggestion that defects in synthesis of viral envelope proteins or processing of F may be an important determinant of persistent infection (Menna et al., ; Young et al., ). Defects in glycoprotein expression may be due in part to limited production of mRNAs for these proteins associated with steep transcriptional gradients and an increase in bicistronic messages (Cattaneo et al., ). However, mutations in these genes are frequent and often lead to the synthesis of proteins with altered expression or function.

Frequent U to C changes suggest that mutation of viral RNA by adenosine deaminase (biased or A/I hypermutation) is occurring in persistently infected cells (Cattaneo et al., ; Wong et al., ; Kuhne et al., ). Failure to recover infectious virus is likely due to the mutations that accumulate in the genes for the M, F, and H envelope proteins that interfere with assembly and budding of infectious virus (Roos et al., ; Baczko et al., ; Cattaneo et al., , ; Jin et al., ). In general, expression of M protein is low (Liebert et al., ) because of either the lack of synthesis of M or to the instability of the synthesized protein (Stephenson et al., ; Sheppard et al., ) and this is accompanied by low levels of antibody to M (Hall et al., ). In addition, defects in the M protein hinder the association of N with the viral glycoproteins and facilitate persistence (Patterson et al., ). Studies in transgenic mice have shown that a functional M protein is not needed for virus replication and spread in the CNS (Cathomen et al., ; Patterson et al., ). Truncations, mutations, and deletions in the cytoplasmic domain of F that interfere with virus budding are almost universal (Schmid et al., ; Cattaneo & Rose, ). H proteins are often defective in intracellular transport and protein–protein interactions important for cell–cell fusion (Cattaneo & Rose, ). It is not known whether these mutations facilitate spread within the CNS and are necessary to establish or perpetuate CNS infection or accumulate because of the lack of selective pressure to maintain envelope functions during replication in the CNS because virus spread can occur trans-synaptically without production of infectious virus.

Concluding remarks

The frequency of MeV RNA persistence in the absence of disease is unknown. MeV has been identified by RT-PCR or morphologic analysis in tissues from normal individuals (Haase et al., ; Schneider-Schaulies et al., ; Katayama et al., , ). In addition to SSPE, MeV antigen or RNA has been described as present and postulated to be playing an etiologic role in a large number of chronic diseases of unknown etiology (e.g. multiple sclerosis, Paget's disease, otosclerosis, chronic active hepatitis, achalasia, and Crohn's disease) (Haase et al., ; Wakefield et al., ; Kawashima et al., ; Friedrichs et al., ; Niedermeyer et al., ). None of these diseases has been convincingly linked to persistent MeV infection, but a better understanding of the immune mechanisms and their regulation necessary for the clearance of virus and viral RNA and of how and where the virus or viral RNA persists could help to determine if a causative role is plausible.

Acknowledgements

Work from the authors’ laboratory was funded by research grants from the National Institutes of Health (R01 AI023047) and the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation.

References

Albertyn
C
van der Plas
H
Hardie
D
Candy
S
Tomoka
T
LeePan
E
&
Heckmann
J
(
2011
)
Silent casualties from the measles outbreak in South Africa
.
S Afr Med J
101
:
313
317
.

Andrejeva
J
Childs
KS
Young
DF
Carlos
TS
Stock
N
Goodbourn
S
&
Randall
RE
(
2004
)
The V proteins of paramyxoviruses bind the IFN-inducible RNA helicase, mda-5, and inhibit its activation of the IFN-beta promoter
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
101
:
17264
17269
.

Andres
O
Obojes
K
Kim
KS
ter Meulen
V
&
Schneider-Schaulies
J
(
2003
)
CD46- and CD150-independent endothelial cell infection with wild-type measles viruses
.
J Gen Virol
84
:
1189
1197
.

Anlar
B
Soylemezoglu
F
Aysun
S
Kose
G
Belen
D
&
Yalaz
K
(
2001
)
Tissue inflammatory response in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE)
.
J Child Neurol
16
:
895
900
.

Auwaerter
PG
Rota
PA
Elkins
WR
Adams
RJ
DeLozier
T
Shi
Y
Bellini
WJ
Murphy
BR
&
Griffin
DE
(
1999
)
Measles virus infection in rhesus macaques: altered immune responses and comparison of the virulence of six different virus strains
.
J Infect Dis
180
:
950
958
.

Baczko
K
Liebert
UG
Billeter
M
Cattaneo
R
Budka
H
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1986
)
Expression of defective measles virus genes in brain tissues of patients with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
J Virol
59
:
472
478
.

Baczko
K
Lampe
J
Liebert
UG
Brinckmann
U
ter Meulen
V
Pardowitz
I
Bucka
H
Cosby
SL
Isserte
S
&
Rima
BK
(
1993
)
Clonal expansion of hypermutated measles virus in a SSPE brain
.
Virology
197
:
188
195
.

Barrett
T
(
1999
)
Morbillivirus infections, with special emphasis on morbilliviruses of carnivores
.
Vet Microbiol
69
:
3
13
.

Bazarsky
E
Wolfson
M
Galron
D
Granot
Y
Argov
S
Isakov
N
&
Rager-Zisman
B
(
1997
)
Persistent measles virus infection of murine neuroblastoma cells differentially affects the expression of PKC individual isoenzymes
.
Virus Genes
15
:
227
234
.

Beckford
AP
Kaschula
ROC
&
Stephen
C
(
1985
)
Factors associated with fatal cases of measles: a retrospective autopsy study
.
S Afr Med J
68
:
858
863
.

Bellini
WJ
Englund
G
Rozenblatt
S
Arnheiter
H
&
Richardson
CD
(
1985
)
Measles virus P gene codes for two proteins
.
J Virol
53
:
908
919
.

Bellini
WJ
Rota
JS
Lowe
LE
Katz
RS
Dyken
PR
Zaki
SR
Shieh
WJ
&
Rota
PA
(
2005
)
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis: more cases of this fatal disease are prevented by measles immunization than was previously recognized
.
J Infect Dis
192
:
1686
1693
.

Bieback
K
Lien
E
Klagge
IM
Avota
E
Schneider-Schaulies
J
Duprex
WP
Wagner
H
Kirschning
CJ
ter Meulen
V
&
Schneider-Schaulies
S
(
2002
)
Hemagglutinin protein of wild-type measles virus activates toll-like receptor 2 signaling
.
J Virol
76
:
8729
8736
.

Brody
JA
Detels
R
&
Sever
JL
(
1972
)
Measles-antibody titres in sibships of patients with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis and controls
.
Lancet
1
:
177
178
.

Burgoon
MP
Keays
KM
Owens
GP
Ritchie
AM
Rai
PR
Cool
CD
&
Gilden
DH
(
2005
)
Laser-capture microdissection of plasma cells from subacute sclerosing panencephalitis brain reveals intrathecal disease-relevant antibodies
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
102
:
7245
7250
.

Burnstein
T
Jacobsen
LB
Zeman
W
&
Chen
TT
(
1974
)
Persistent infection of BSC-1 cells by defective measles virus derived from subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
Infect Immun
10
:
1378
1382
.

Caignard
G
Guerbois
M
Labernardiere
JL
Jacob
Y
Jones
LM
Wild
F
Tangy
F
&
Vidalain
PO
(
2007
)
Measles virus V protein blocks Jak1-mediated phosphorylation of STAT1 to escape IFN-alpha/beta signaling
.
Virology
368
:
351
362
.

Caignard
G
Bourai
M
Jacob
Y
Tangy
F
&
Vidalain
PO
(
2009
)
Inhibition of IFN-alpha/beta signaling by two discrete peptides within measles virus V protein that specifically bind STAT1 and STAT2
.
Virology
383
:
112
120
.

Campbell
H
Andrews
N
Brown
KE
&
Miller
E
(
2007
)
Review of the effect of measles vaccination on the epidemiology of SSPE
.
Int J Epidemiol
36
:
1334
1348
.

Cathomen
T
Mrkic
B
Spehner
D
Drillien
R
Naef
R
Pavlovic
J
Aguzzi
A
Billeter
MA
&
Cattaneo
R
(
1998
)
A matrix-less measles virus is infectious and elicits extensive cell fusion: consequences for propagation in the brain
.
EMBO J
17
:
3899
3908
.

Cattaneo
R
&
Rose
JK
(
1993
)
Cell fusion by the envelope glycoproteins of persistent measles viruses which caused lethal human brain disease
.
J Virol
67
:
1493
1502
.

Cattaneo
R
Schmid
A
Rebmann
G
Baczko
K
ter Meulen
V
Bellini
WJ
Rozenblatt
S
&
Billeter
MA
(
1986
)
Accumulated measles virus mutations in a case of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis. Interrupted matrix protein reading frame and transcription alteration
.
Virology
154
:
97
109
.

Cattaneo
R
Rebmann
G
Schmid
A
Baczko
K
ter Meulen
V
&
Billeter
MA
(
1987
)
Altered transcription of a defective measles virus genome derived from a diseased human brain
.
EMBO J
6
:
681
688
.

Cattaneo
R
Schmid
A
Billeter
MA
Sheppard
RD
&
Udem
SA
(
1988a
)
Multiple viral mutations rather than host factors cause defective measles virus gene expression in a subacute sclerosing panencephalitis cell line
.
J Virol
62
:
1388
1397
.

Cattaneo
R
Schmid
A
Eschle
D
Baczko
K
ter Meulen
V
&
Billeter
MA
(
1988b
)
Biased hypermutation and other genetic changes in defective measles viruses in human brain infections
.
Cell
55
:
255
265
.

Cattaneo
R
Kaelin
K
Baczko
K
&
Billeter
MA
(
1989a
)
Measles virus editing provides an additional cysteine-rich protein
.
Cell
56
:
759
764
.

Cattaneo
R
Schmid
A
Spielhofer
P
et al. (
1989b
)
Mutated and hypermutated genes of persistent measles viruses which caused lethal human brain diseases
.
Virology
173
:
415
425
.

Centers for Disease Control
(
2009
)
Global Measles Mortality, 2000–2008
.
MMWR
58
:
1321
1326
.

Childs
KS
Andrejeva
J
Randall
RE
&
Goodbourn
S
(
2009
)
Mechanism of mda-5 Inhibition by paramyxovirus V proteins
.
J Virol
83
:
1465
1473
.

Colf
LA
Juo
ZS
&
Garcia
KC
(
2007
)
Structure of the measles virus hemagglutinin
.
Nat Struct Mol Biol
14
:
1227
1228
.

Condack
C
Grivel
JC
Devaux
P
Margolis
L
&
Cattaneo
R
(
2007
)
Measles virus vaccine attenuation: suboptimal infection of lymphatic tissue and tropism alteration
.
J Infect Dis
196
:
541
549
.

Dawson
JR
(
1934
)
Cellular inclusions in cerebral lesions of epidemic encephalitis
.
Arch Neurol Psychiatry
31
:
685
700
.

de Swart
RL
Ludlow
M
de Witte
L
Yanagi
Y
van Amerongen
G
McQuaid
S
Yuksel
S
Geijtenbeek
TBH
Duprex
WP
&
Osterhaus
A
(
2007
)
Predominant infection of CD150+ lymphocytes and dendritic cells during measles virus infection of macaques
.
PLoS Pathog
3
:
1771
1781
.

de Vries
RD
Yuksel
S
Osterhaus
AD
&
de Swart
RL
(
2010
)
Specific CD8(+) T-lymphocytes control dissemination of measles virus
.
Eur J Immunol
40
:
388
395
.

Detels
R
Brody
JA
McNew
J
&
Edgar
AH
(
1973
)
Further epidemiological studies of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
Lancet
2
:
11
14
.

Devaux
P
Hudacek
AW
Hodge
G
Reyes-Del Valle
J
McChesney
MB
&
Cattaneo
R
(
2011
)
A recombinant measles virus unable to antagonize STAT1 function cannot control inflammation and is attenuated in rhesus monkeys
.
J Virol
85
:
348
356
.

Dittmar
S
Harms
H
Runkler
N
Maisner
A
Kim
KS
&
Schneider-Schaulies
J
(
2008
)
Measles virus-induced block of transendothelial migration of T lymphocytes and infection-mediated virus spread across endothelial cell barriers
.
J Virol
82
:
11273
11282
.

Dorig
RE
Marcil
A
Chopra
A
&
Richardson
CD
(
1993
)
The human CD46 molecule is a receptor for measles virus (Edmonston strain)
.
Cell
75
:
295
305
.

Dubois-Dalcq
M
Coblentz
JM
&
Pleet
AB
(
1974
)
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis: unusual nuclear inclusions and lengthy clinical course
.
Arch Neurol
31
:
355
363
.

Duhen
T
Herschke
F
Azocar
O
et al. (
2010
)
Cellular receptors, differentiation and endocytosis requirements are key factors for type I IFN response by human epithelial, conventional and plasmacytoid dendritic infected cells by measles virus
.
Virus Res
152
:
115
125
.

Duprex
WP
McQuaid
S
Roscic-Mrkic
B
Cattaneo
R
McCallister
C
&
Rima
BK
(
2000
)
In vitro and in vivo infection of neural cells by a recombinant measles virus expressing enhanced green fluorescent protein
.
J Virol
74
:
7972
7979
.

Ehrengruber
MU
Ehler
E
Billeter
M
&
Naim
HY
(
2002
)
Measles virus spreads in rat hippocampal neurons by cell-to-cell contact and in a polarized fashion
.
J Virol
76
:
5720
5728
.

Embree
JE
Datta
P
Stackiw
W
Sekla
L
Braddick
M
Kreiss
JK
Pamba
H
Wamola
I
Ndinya-Achola
JO
&
Law
BJ
(
1992
)
Increased risk of early measles in infants of human immunodeficiency virus type 1-seropositive mothers
.
J Infect Dis
165
:
262
267
.

Enders
JF
McCarthy
K
Mitus
A
&
Cheatham
WJ
(
1959
)
Isolation of measles virus at autopsy in cases of giant cell pneumonia without rash
.
N Engl J Med
261
:
875
881
.

Endo
A
Izumi
H
Miyashita
M
Taniguchi
K
Okubo
O
&
Harada
K
(
2001
)
Current efficacy of postexposure prophylaxis against measles with immunoglobulin
.
J Pediatr
138
:
926
928
.

Erlenhofer
C
Duprex
WP
Rima
BK
ter Meulen
V
&
Schneider-Schaulies
J
(
2002
)
Analysis of receptor (CD46, CD150) usage by measles virus
.
J Gen Virol
83
:
1431
1436
.

Esiri
MM
Oppenheimer
DR
Brownell
B
&
Haire
M
(
1982
)
Distribution of measles antigen and immunoglobulin containing cells in the CNS in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) and atypical measles encephalitis
.
J Neurol Sci
53
:
29
43
.

Esolen
LM
Takahashi
K
Johnson
RT
Vaisberg
A
Moench
TR
Wesselingh
SL
&
Griffin
DE
(
1995
)
Brain endothelial cell infection in children with acute fatal measles
.
J Clin Invest
96
:
2478
2481
.

Fernandez-Munoz
R
&
Celma
ML
(
1992
)
Measles virus from a long-term persistently infected human T lymphoblastoid cell line, in contrast to the cytocidal parental virus, establishes an immediate persistence in the original cell line
.
J Gen Virol
73
:
2195
2202
.

Finke
D
Brinckmann
UG
ter Meulen
V
&
Liebert
UG
(
1995
)
Gamma interferon is a major mediator of antiviral defense in experimental measles virus-induced encephalitis
.
J Virol
69
:
5469
5474
.

Fishman
D
Wolfson
M
Bazarski
E
Segal
S
&
Rager-Zisman
B
(
1997
)
The effects of measles virus persistent infection on AP-1 transcription factor binding in neuroblastoma cells
.
FEBS Lett
410
:
191
194
.

Freeman
JM
Magoffin
RL
Lennette
EH
&
Herndon
RM
(
1967
)
Additional evidence of the relation between subacute inclusion-body encephalitis and measles virus
.
Lancet
2
:
129
131
.

Friedrichs
WE
Reddy
SV
Bruder
JM
Cundy
T
Cornish
J
Singer
FR
&
Roodman
GD
(
2002
)
Sequence analysis of measles virus nucleocapsid transcripts in patients with Paget's disease
.
J Bone Miner Res
17
:
145
151
.

Fujinami
RS
&
Oldstone
MBA
(
1979
)
Antiviral antibody reacting on the plasma membrane alters measles virus expression inside the cell
.
Nature
279
:
529
530
.

Furuse
Y
Suzuki
A
&
Oshitani
H
(
2010
)
Origin of measles virus: divergence from rinderpest virus between the 11th and 12th centuries
.
Virol J
7
:
52
.

Garenne
M
(
1994
)
Sex differences in measles mortality: a world review
.
Int J Epidemiol
23
:
632
642
.

Good
RA
&
Zak
SJ
(
1956
)
Disturbances in gammaglobulin synthesis as “experiments of nature”
.
Pediatrics
18
:
109
149
.

Grais
RF
Dubray
C
&
Gerstl
Seal
(
2007
)
Unacceptably high mortality related to measles epidemics in Niger, Nigeria, and Chad
.
PLoS Med
4
:
0122
0129
.

Griffin
DE
Ward
BJ
Jauregui
E
Johnson
RT
&
Vaisberg
A
(
1990
)
Natural killer cell activity during measles
.
Clin Exp Immunol
81
:
218
224
.

Haase
AT
Ventura
P
Gibbs
CJ
Jr
&
Tourtellotte
WW
(
1981
)
Measles virus nucleotide sequences: detection by hybridization in situ
.
Science
212
:
672
675
.

Haase
AT
Stowring
L
Ventura
P
Burks
J
Ebers
G
Tourtellotte
W
&
Warren
K
(
1984
)
Detection by hybridization of viral infection of the human central nervous system
.
Ann N Y Acad Sci
436
:
103
108
.

Hall
WW
Lamb
RA
&
Choppin
PW
(
1979
)
Measles and subacute sclerosing panencephalitis virus proteins: lack of antibodies to the M protein in patients with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
76
:
2047
2051
.

Halsey
NA
Modlin
JF
Jabbour
JT
Dubey
L
Eddins
DL
&
Ludwig
DD
(
1980
)
Risk factors in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis: a case–control study
.
Am J Epidemiol
111
:
415
424
.

Hashiguchi
T
Kajikawa
M
Maita
N
Takeda
M
Kuroki
K
Sasaki
K
Kohda
D
Yanagi
Y
&
Maenaka
K
(
2007
)
Crystal structure of measles virus hemagglutinin provides insight into effective vaccines
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
104
:
19535
19540
.

Hashiguchi
T
Ose
T
Kubota
M
Maita
N
Kamishikiryo
J
Maenaka
K
&
Yanagi
Y
(
2011
)
Structure of the measles virus hemagglutinin bound to its cellular receptor SLAM
.
Nat Struct Mol Biol
18
:
135
141
.

He
B
Paterson
RG
Stock
N
Durbin
JE
Durbin
RK
Goodbourn
S
Randall
RE
&
Lamb
RA
(
2002
)
Recovery of paramyxovirus simian virus 5 with a V protein lacking the conserved cysteine-rich domain: the multifunctional V protein blocks both interferon-beta induction and interferon signaling
.
Virology
303
:
15
32
.

Helin
E
Vainionpaa
R
Hyypia
T
Julkunen
I
&
Matikainen
S
(
2001
)
Measles virus activates NF-kappa B and STAT transcription factors and production of IFN-alpha/beta and IL-6 in the human lung epithelial cell line A549
.
Virology
290
:
1
10
.

Herndon
RM
&
Rubinstein
LJ
(
1968
)
Light and electron microscopy observations on the development of viral particles in the inclusions of Dawson's encephalitis (subacute sclerosing panencephalitis)
.
Neurology
18
:
8
20
.

Horzinek
MC
(
2011
)
Rinderpest: the second viral disease eradicated
.
Vet Microbiol
149
:
295
297
.

Indoh
T
Yokota
S
Okabayashi
T
Yokosawa
N
&
Fujii
N
(
2007
)
Suppression of NF-kappaB and AP-1 activation in monocytic cells persistently infected with measles virus
.
Virology
361
:
294
303
.

Jabbour
JT
Duenas
DA
Sever
JL
Krebs
HM
&
Horta-Barbosa
L
(
1972
)
Epidemiology of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis: a report of the SSPE registry
.
J Am Med Assoc
220
:
959
962
.

Jaye
A
Magnusen
AF
Sadiq
AD
Corrrah
T
&
Whittle
HC
(
1998
)
Ex vivo analysis of cytotoxic T lymphocytes to measles antigens during infection and after vaccination in Gambian children
.
J Clin Invest
102
:
1969
1977
.

Jin
L
Beard
S
Hunjan
R
Brown
DW
&
Miller
E
(
2002
)
Characterization of measles virus strains causing SSPE: a study of 11 cases
.
J Neurovirol
8
:
335
344
.

Kaiserlian
D
&
Dubois
B
(
2001
)
Dendritic cells and viral immunity: friends or foes?
Semin Immunol
13
:
303
310
.

Katayama
Y
Hotta
H
Nishimura
A
Tatsuno
Y
&
Homma
M
(
1995
)
Detection of measles virus nucleoprotein mRNA in autopsied brain tissues
.
J Gen Virol
76
:
3201
3204
.

Katayama
Y
Kohso
K
Nishimura
A
Tatsuno
Y
Homma
M
&
Hotta
H
(
1998
)
Detection of measles virus mRNA from autopsied human tissues
.
J Clin Microbiol
36
:
299
301
.

Katayama
Y
Hirano
A
&
Wong
TC
(
2000
)
Human receptor for measles virus (CD46) enhances nitric oxide production and restricts virus replication in mouse macrophages by modulating production of alpha/beta interferon
.
J Virol
74
:
1252
1257
.

Kawashima
H
Miyajima
T
Mori
T
Yuan
L
Ogihara
M
Kinoue
K
Takekuma
K
&
Hoshika
A
(
1996
)
A case of intractable epilepsy positive for the detection of measles virus genome in the cerebrospinal fluid and peripheral mononuclear cells using reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction
.
Brain Dev
18
:
220
223
.

Kemper
C
Chan
AC
Green
JM
Brett
KA
Murphy
KM
&
Atkinson
JP
(
2003
)
Activation of human CD4+ cells with CD3 and CD46 induces a T-regulatory cell 1 phenotype
.
Nature
421
:
388
392
.

Kirk
JL
Zhou
AL
McQuaid
S
Cosby
SL
&
Allen
IV
(
1991
)
Cerebral endothelial cell infection by measles virus in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis: ultrastructural and in situ hybridization evidence
.
Neuropathol Appl Neurobiol
17
:
289
297
.

Koschel
K
Brinckmann
U
&
Hoyningen-Huene
VK
(
1995
)
Measles virus antisense sequences specifically cure cells persistently infected with measles virus
.
Virology
207
:
168
178
.

Kouomou
DW
&
Wild
TF
(
2002
)
Adaptation of wild-type measles virus to tissue culture
.
J Virol
76
:
1505
1509
.

Kuhne
M
Brown
DW
&
Jin
L
(
2006
)
Genetic variability of measles virus in acute and persistent infections
.
Infect Genet Evol
6
:
269
276
.

Lawrence
DM
Patterson
CE
Gales
TL
D'Orazio
JL
Vaughn
MM
&
Rall
GF
(
2000
)
Measles virus spread between neurons requires cell contact but not CD46 expression, syncytium formation, or extracellular virus production
.
J Virol
74
:
1908
1918
.

Lemon
K
de Vries
RD
Mesman
AW
et al. (
2011
)
Early target cells of measles virus after aerosol infection of non-human primates
.
PLoS Pathog
7
:
e1001263
.

Leopardi
R
Hyypia
T
&
Vainionpaa
R
(
1992
)
Effect of interferon-alpha on measles virus replication in human peripheral blood mononuclear cells
.
APMIS
100
:
125
131
.

Lessler
J
Reich
NG
Brookmeyer
R
Perl
TM
Nelson
KE
&
Cummings
DA
(
2009
)
Incubation periods of acute respiratory viral infections: a systematic review
.
Lancet Infect Dis
9
:
291
300
.

Liebert
UG
Baczko
K
Budka
H
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1986
)
Restricted expression of measles virus proteins in brains from cases of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
J Gen Virol
67
:
2435
2444
.

Liebert
UG
Schneider-Schaulies
S
Baczko
K
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1990
)
Antibody-induced restriction of viral gene expression in measles encephalitis in rats
.
J Virol
64
:
706
713
.

Liston
P
&
Briedis
DJ
(
1994
)
Measles virus V protein binds zinc
.
Virology
198
:
399
404
.

Ludlow
M
Allen
I
&
Schneider-Schaulies
J
(
2009
)
Systemic spread of measles virus: overcoming the epithelial and endothelial barriers
.
Thromb Haemost
102
:
1050
1056
.

Makhortova
NR
Askovich
P
Patterson
CE
Gechman
LA
Gerard
NP
&
Rall
GF
(
2007
)
Neurokinin-1 enables measles virus trans-synaptic spread in neurons
.
Virology
362
:
235
244
.

Masse
N
Ainouze
M
Neel
B
Wild
TF
Buckland
R
&
Langedijk
JP
(
2004
)
Measles virus (MV) hemagglutinin: evidence that attachment sites for MV receptors SLAM and CD46 overlap on the globular head
.
J Virol
78
:
9051
9063
.

McQuaid
S
&
Cosby
SL
(
2002
)
An immunohistochemical study of the distribution of the measles virus receptors, CD46 and SLAM, in normal human tissues and subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
Lab Invest
82
:
403
409
.

McQuaid
S
Cosby
SL
Koffi
K
Honde
M
Kirk
J
&
Lucas
SB
(
1998
)
Distribution of measles virus in the central nervous system of HIV-seropositive children
.
Acta Neuropathol
96
:
637
642
.

Menna
HH
Collins
AR
&
Flanagan
TD
(
1975
)
Characterization of an in vitro persistent-state measles virus infection: establishment and virological characterization of the BGM/MV cell line
.
Infect Immun
11
:
152
158
.

Miller
CA
&
Carrigan
DR
(
1982
)
Reversible repression and activation of measles virus infection in neuronal cells
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
79
:
1629
1633
.

Miller
C
Farrington
CP
&
Harbert
K
(
1992
)
The epidemiology of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis in England and Wales 1970-1989
.
Int J Epidemiol
21
:
998
1006
.

Modlin
JF
Jabbour
JT
Witte
JJ
&
Halsey
NA
(
1977
)
Epidemiologic studies of measles, measles vaccine, and subacute sclerosing encephalitis
.
Pediatrics
59
:
505
512
.

Moench
TR
Griffin
DE
Obriecht
CR
Vaisberg
AJ
&
Johnson
RT
(
1988
)
Acute measles in patients with and without neurological involvement: distribution of measles virus antigen and RNA
.
J Infect Dis
158
:
433
442
.

Mongkolsapaya
J
Jaye
A
Callan
MFC
Magnusen
AF
McMichael
AJ
&
Whittle
HC
(
1999
)
Antigen-specific expansion of cytotoxic T lymphocytes in acute measles virus infection
.
J Virol
73
:
67
71
.

Moss
WJ
(
2007
)
Measles still has a devastating impact in unvaccinated populations
.
PLoS Med
4
:
e24
.

Moss
WJ
&
Griffin
DE
(
2006
)
Global measles elimination
.
Nat Rev Microbiol
4
:
900
908
.

Moss
WJ
Monze
M
Ryon
JJ
Quinn
TC
Griffin
DE
&
Cutts
F
(
2002a
)
Prospective study of measles in hospitalized, human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-infected and HIV-uninfected children in Zambia
.
Clin Infect Dis
35
:
189
196
.

Moss
WJ
Ryon
JJ
Monze
M
&
Griffin
DE
(
2002b
)
Differential regulation of interleukin (IL)-4, IL-5, and IL-10 during measles in Zambian children
.
J Infect Dis
186
:
879
887
.

Moss
WJ
Fisher
C
Scott
S
Monze
M
Ryon
JJ
Quinn
TC
Griffin
DE
&
Cutts
FT
(
2008
)
HIV type 1 infection is a risk factor for mortality in hospitalized Zambian children with measles
.
Clin Infect Dis
46
:
523
527
.

Muhlebach
MD
Mateo
M
Sinn
PL
et al. (
2011
)
Adherens junction protein nectin-4 is the epithelial receptor for measles virus
.
Nature
480
:
530
533
.

Muscat
M
Bang
H
Wohlfahrt
J
Glismann
S
&
Molbak
K
(
2009
)
Measles in Europe: an epidemiological assessment
.
Lancet
373
:
383
389
.

Myou
S
Fujimura
M
Yasui
M
Ueno
T
&
Matsuda
T
(
1993
)
Bronchoalveolar lavage cell analysis in measles viral pneumonia
.
Eur Respir J
6
:
1437
1442
.

Nandy
R
Handzel
T
Zaneidou
M
Biey
J
Coddy
RZ
Perry
R
Strebel
P
&
Cairns
L
(
2006
)
Case-fatality rate during a measles outbreak in eastern Niger in 2003
.
Clin Infect Dis
42
:
322
328
.

Naniche
D
Varior-Krishnan
G
Cervoni
F
Wild
F
Rossi
B
Rabourdin-Combe
C
&
Gerlier
D
(
1993
)
Human membrane cofactor protein (CD46) acts as a cellular receptor for measles virus
.
J Virol
67
:
6025
6032
.

Naniche
D
Yeh
A
Eto
DS
Manchester
M
Friedman
R
&
Oldstone
BA
(
2000
)
Evasion of host defenses by measles virus: wild-type measles virus infection interferes with induction of alpha/beta interferon production
.
J Virol
74
:
7478
7484
.

Niedermeyer
HP
Gantumur
T
Neubert
WJ
&
Arnold
W
(
2007
)
Measles virus and otosclerosis
.
Adv Otorhinolaryngol
65
:
86
92
.

Noyce
RS
Bondre
DG
Lin
L-T
Sisson
G
Tsao
MS
Richardson
CD
&
Ha
MN
(
2011
)
Tumor cell marker PVRL4 (Nectin 4) is an epithelial cell receptor for measles virus
.
PLoS Pathog
7
:
1002240
.

Obojes
K
Andres
O
Kim
KS
Daubener
W
&
Schneider-Schaulies
J
(
2005
)
Indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase mediates cell type-specific anti-measles virus activity of gamma interferon
.
J Virol
79
:
7768
7776
.

Ohno
S
Seki
F
Ono
N
&
Yanagi
Y
(
2003
)
Histidine at position 61 and its adjacent amino acid residues are critical for the ability of SLAM (CD150) to act as a cellular receptor for measles virus
.
J Gen Virol
84
:
2381
2388
.

Oldstone
MB
Homann
D
Lewicki
H
&
Stevenson
D
(
2002
)
One, two, or three step: measles virus receptor dance
.
Virology
299
:
162
163
.

Oldstone
MBA
Dales
S
Tishon
A
Lewicki
H
&
Martin
L
(
2005
)
A role for dual viral hits in causation of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
J Exp Med
202
:
1185
1190
.

Ono
N
Tatsuo
H
Hidaka
Y
Aoki
T
&
Minagawa
HY
(
2001
)
Measles viruses on throat swabs from measles patients use signaling lymphocytic activation molecule (CDw150) but not CD46 as a cellular receptor
.
J Virol
75
:
4399
4401
.

Palosaari
H
Parisien
JP
Rodriguez
JJ
Ulane
CM
&
Horvath
CM
(
2003
)
STAT protein interference and suppression of cytokine signal transduction by measles virus V protein
.
J Virol
77
:
7635
7644
.

Pan
CH
Valsamakis
A
Colella
T
Nair
N
Adams
RJ
Polack
FP
Greer
CE
Perri
S
Polo
JM
&
Griffin
DE
(
2005
)
Inaugural Article: modulation of disease, T cell responses, and measles virus clearance in monkeys vaccinated with H-encoding alphavirus replicon particles
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
102
:
11581
11588
.

Patterson
JB
Cornu
TI
Redwine
J
Dales
S
Lewicki
HA
Holz
A
Thomas
D
Billeter
M
&
Oldstone
MBA
(
2001
)
Evidence that the hypermutated M protein of a subacute sclerosing panencephalitis measles virus actively contributes to the chronic progressive CNS disease
.
Virology
291
:
215
225
.

Patterson
CE
Lawrence
DM
Echols
LA
&
Rall
GF
(
2002
)
Immune-mediated protection from measles virus-induced central nervous system disease is noncytolytic and gamma interferon dependent
.
J Virol
76
:
4497
4506
.

Permar
SR
Moss
WJ
Ryon
JJ
Monze
M
Cutts
F
Quinn
TC
&
Griffin
DE
(
2001
)
Prolonged measles virus shedding in human immunodeficiency virus-infected children, detected by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction
.
J Infect Dis
183
:
532
538
.

Permar
SR
Klumpp
SA
Mansfield
KG
et al. (
2003
)
Role of CD8(+) lymphocytes in control and clearance of measles virus infection of rhesus monkeys
.
J Virol
77
:
4396
4400
.

Permar
SR
Klumpp
SA
Mansfield
KG
et al. (
2004
)
Limited contribution of humoral immunity to the clearance of measles viremia in rhesus monkeys
.
J Infect Dis
190
:
998
1005
.

Pfaller
CK
&
Conzelmann
KK
(
2008
)
Measles virus V protein is a decoy substrate for IkappaB kinase alpha and prevents Toll-like receptor 7/9-mediated interferon induction
.
J Virol
82
:
12365
12373
.

Plaza
JA
&
Nuovo
GJ
(
2005
)
Histologic and molecular correlates of fatal measles infection in children
.
Diagn Mol Pathol
14
:
97
102
.

Polack
FP
Auwaerter
PG
Lee
S-H
Nousari
HC
Valsamakis
A
Leiferman
KM
Diwan
A
Adams
RJ
&
Griffin
DE
(
1999
)
Production of atypical measles in rhesus macaques: evidence for disease mediated by immune complex formation and eosinophils in the presence of fusion-inhibiting antibody
.
Nat Med
5
:
629
634
.

Pueschel
K
Tietz
A
Carsillo
M
Steward
M
&
Niewiesk
S
(
2007
)
Measles virus-specific CD4 T-cell activity does not correlate with protection against lung infection or viral clearance
.
J Virol
81
:
8571
8578
.

Rager-Zisman
B
Egan
JE
Kress
Y
&
Bloom
BR
(
1984
)
Isolation of cold-sensitive mutants of measles virus from persistently infected murine neuroblastoma cells
.
J Virol
51
:
845
855
.

Ramachandran
A
&
Horvath
CM
(
2010
)
Dissociation of paramyxovirus interferon evasion activities: universal and virus-specific requirements for conserved V protein amino acids in MDA5 interference
.
J Virol
84
:
11152
11163
.

Ramachandran
A
Parisien
JP
&
Horvath
CM
(
2008
)
STAT2 is a primary target for measles virus V protein-mediated alpha/beta interferon signaling inhibition
.
J Virol
82
:
8330
8338
.

Rammohan
KW
McFarland
HF
&
McFarlin
DE
(
1981
)
Induction of subacute murine measles encephalitis by monoclonal antibody to virus haemagglutinin
.
Nature
290
:
588
589
.

Rammohan
KW
McFarland
HF
&
McFarlin
DE
(
1982
)
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis after passive immunization and natural measles infection: role of antibody in persistence of measles virus
.
Neurology
32
:
390
394
.

Richard
JL
&
Masserey Spicher
V
(
2009
)
Large measles epidemic in Switzerland from 2006 to 2009: consequences for the elimination of measles in Europe
.
Euro Surveill
14
:
1
9
.

Riddell
MA
Moss
WJ
Hauer
D
Monze
M
&
Griffin
D
(
2007
)
Slow clearance of measles virus RNA after acute infection
.
J Clin Virol
39
:
312
317
.

Riley-Vargas
RC
Gill
DB
Kemper
C
Liszewski
MK
&
Atkinson
JP
(
2004
)
CD46: expanding beyond complement regulation
.
Trends Immunol
25
:
496
503
.

Rima
BK
&
Duprex
WP
(
2005
)
Molecular mechanisms of measles virus persistence
.
Virus Res
111
:
132
147
.

Rima
BK
Davidson
WB
&
Martin
SJ
(
1977
)
The role of defective interfering particles in persistent infection of Vero cells by measles virus
.
J Gen Virol
35
:
89
97
.

Rima
BK
Earle
JAP
Yeo
RP
Herlihy
L
Baczko
K
ter Meulen
V
Carabana
J
Caballero
M
Celma
ML
&
Fernandez-Munoz
R
(
1995
)
Temporal and geographical distribution of measles virus genotypes
.
J Gen Virol
76
:
1173
1180
.

Robinzon
S
Dafa-Berger
A
Dyer
MD
Paeper
B
Proll
SC
Teal
TH
Rom
S
Fishman
D
Rager-Zisman
B
&
Katze
MG
(
2009
)
Impaired cholesterol biosynthesis in a neuronal cell line persistently infected with measles virus
.
J Virol
83
:
5495
5504
.

Roos
RP
Graves
MC
Wollmann
RL
Chilcote
RR
&
Nixon
J
(
1981
)
Immunologic and virologic studies of measles inclusion body encephalitis in an immunosuppressed host: the relationship to subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
Neurology
31
:
1263
1270
.

Rustigian
R
(
1966
)
Persistent infection of cells in culture by measles virus. I. Development and characteristics of HeLa sublines persistently infected with complete virus
.
J Bacteriol
92
:
1792
1804
.

Saha
V
John
TJ
Mukundan
P
Gnanamuthu
C
Prabhakar
S
Arjundas
G
Sayeed
ZA
Kumaresan
G
&
Srinivas
K
(
1990
)
High incidence of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis in south India
.
Epidemiol Infect
104
:
151
156
.

Santiago
C
Bjorling
E
Stehle
T
&
Casasnovas
JM
(
2002
)
Distinct kinetics for binding of the CD46 and SLAM receptors to overlapping sites in the measles virus hemagglutinin protein
.
J Biol Chem
277
:
32294
32301
.

Santiago
C
Celma
ML
Stehle
T
&
Casasnovas
JM
(
2010
)
Structure of the measles virus hemagglutinin bound to the CD46 receptor
.
Nat Struct Mol Biol
17
:
124
129
.

Sato
H
Honma
R
Yoneda
M
Miura
R
Tsukiyama-Kohara
K
Ikeda
F
Seki
T
Watanabe
S
&
Kai
C
(
2008
)
Measles virus induces cell-type specific changes in gene expression
.
Virology
375
:
321
330
.

Sawaishi
Y
Yano
T
Wantanabe
Y
&
Takada
G
(
1999
)
Migratory basal ganglia lesions in subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE): clinical implications of axonal spread
.
J Neurol Sci
168
:
137
140
.

Schlender
J
Hornung
V
Finke
S
Gunthner-Biller
M
Marozin
S
Brzozka
K
Moghim
S
Endres
S
Hartmann
G
&
Conzelmann
KK
(
2005
)
Inhibition of toll-like receptor 7- and 9-mediated alpha/beta interferon production in human plasmacytoid dendritic cells by respiratory syncytial virus and measles virus
.
J Virol
79
:
5507
5515
.

Schmid
A
Spielhofer
P
Cattaneo
R
Baczko
K
ter Meulen
V
&
Billeter
MA
(
1992
)
Subacute sclerosing panencephalitis is typically characterized by alterations in the fusion protein cytoplasmic domain of the persisting measles virus
.
Virology
188
:
910
915
.

Schneider
U
von Messling
V
Devaux
P
&
Cattaneo
R
(
2002
)
Efficiency of measles virus entry and dissemination through different receptors
.
J Virol
76
:
7460
7467
.

Schneider-Schaulies
S
Kreth
HW
Hofmann
G
Billeter
M
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1991
)
Expression of measles virus RNA in peripheral blood mononuclear cells of patients with measles, SSPE, and autoimmune diseases
.
Virology
182
:
703
711
.

Schneider-Schaulies
S
Schneider-Schaulies
J
Schuster
A
Bayer
M
Pavlovic
J
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1994
)
Cell type-specific MxA-mediated inhibition of measles virus transcription in human brain cells
.
J Virol
68
:
6910
6917
.

Schneider-Schaulies
S
Bieback
K
Avota
E
Klagge
I
&
ter Meulen
V
(
2002
)
Regulation of gene expression in lymphocytes and antigen-presenting cells by measles virus: consequences for immunomodulation
.
J Mol Med
80
:
73
85
.

Schnorr
J-J
Schneider-Schaulies
S
Simon-Jodicke
A
Pavlovic
J
Horisberger
MA
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1993
)
MxA-dependent inhibition of measles virus glycoprotein synthesis in a stably transfected human monocytic cell line
.
J Virol
67
:
4760
4768
.

Schuhmann
KM
Pfaller
CK
&
Conzelmann
KK
(
2011
)
The measles virus V protein binds to p65 (RelA) to suppress NF-kappaB activity
.
J Virol
85
:
3162
3171
.

Shanks
GD
Lee
S-H
Howard
A
&
Brunden
KR
(
2011
)
Extreme mortality after first introduction of measles virus to the Polynesian Island of Rotuma, 1911
.
Am J Epidemiol
173
:
1211
1222
.

Sheppard
RD
Raine
CS
Bornstein
MB
&
Udem
SA
(
1986
)
Rapid degradation restricts measles virus matrix protein expression in a subacute sclerosing panencephalitis cell line
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
83
:
7913
7917
.

Shingai
M
Ayata
M
Ishida
H
Matsunaga
I
Katayama
Y
Seya
T
Tatsuo
H
Yanagi
Y
&
Ogura
H
(
2003
)
Receptor use by vesicular stomatitis virus pseudotypes with glycoproteins of defective variants of measles virus isolated from brains of patients with subacute sclerosing panencephalitis
.
J Gen Virol
84
:
2133
2143
.

Shirogane
Y
Takeda
M
Tahara
M
Ikegame
S
Nakamura
T
&
Yanagi
Y
(
2010
)
Epithelial-mesenchymal transition abolishes the susceptibility of polarized epithelial cell lines to measles virus
.
J Biol Chem
285
:
20882
20890
.

Sidorenko
SP
&
Clark
EA
(
2003
)
The dual-function CD150 receptor subfamily: the viral attraction
.
Nat Immunol
4
:
19
24
.

Sinn
PL
Williams
G
Vongpunsawad
S
Cattaneo
R
&
McCray
PB
Jr
(
2002
)
Measles virus preferentially transduces the basolateral surface of well-differentiated human airway epithelia
.
J Virol
76
:
2403
2409
.

Stephenson
JR
Siddell
SG
&
ter Meulen
V
(
1981
)
Persistent and lytic infections with SSPE virus: a comparison of the synthesis of virus-specific polypeptides
.
J Gen Virol
57
:
191
197
.

Stubblefield
P
Sr
Widness
M
Levine
AD
&
Patterson
CE
(
2011
)
T cell-, interleukin-12-, and gamma interferon-driven viral clearance in measles virus-infected brain tissue
.
J Virol
85
:
3664
3676
.

Takahashi
M
Watari
E
Shinya
E
Shimizu
T
&
Takahashi
H
(
2007
)
Suppression of virus replication via down-modulation of mitochondrial short chain enoyl-CoA hydratase in human glioblastoma cells
.
Antiviral Res
75
:
152
158
.

Takaki
H
Watanabe
Y
Shingai
M
Oshiumi
H
Matsumoto
M
&
Seya
T
(
2011
)
Strain-to-strain difference of V protein of measles virus affects MDA5-mediated IFN-beta-inducing potential
.
Mol Immunol
48
:
497
504
.

Takasu
T
Mgone
JM
Mgone
CS
et al. (
2003
)
A continuing high incidence of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis (SSPE) in the Eastern Highlands of Papua New Guinea
.
Epidemiol Infect
131
:
887
898
.

Takeuchi
K
Takeda
M
Miyajima
N
Kobune
F
Tanabayashi
K
&
Tashiro
M
(
2002
)
Recombinant wild-type and Edmonston strain measles viruses bearing heterologous H proteins: role of H protein in cell fusion and host cell specificity
.
J Virol
76
:
4891
4900
.

Takeuchi
K
Miyajima
N
Nagata
N
Takeda
M
&
Tashiro
M
(
2003
)
Wild-type measles virus induces large syncytium formation in primary human small airway epithelial cells by a SLAM(CD150)-independent mechanism
.
Virus Res
94
:
11
16
.

Tamashiro
VG
Perez
HH
&
Griffin
DE
(
1987
)
Prospective study of the magnitude and duration of changes in tuberculin reactivity during complicated and uncomplicated measles
.
Pediatr Infect Dis J
6
:
451
454
.

Tanabe
M
Kurita-Taniguchi
M
Takeuchi
K
Takeda
M
Ayata
M
Ogura
H
Matsumoto
M
&
Seya
T
(
2003
)
Mechanism of up-regulation of human toll-like receptor 3 secondary to infection of measles virus-attenuated strains
.
Biochem Biophys Res Commun
311
:
39
48
.

Tatsuo
H
Ono
N
Tanaka
K
&
Yanagi
Y
(
2000
)
SLAM (CDw150) is a cellular receptor for measles virus
.
Nature
406
:
893
898
.

Tenoever
BR
Servant
MJ
Grandvaux
N
Lin
R
&
Hiscott
J
(
2002
)
Recognition of the measles virus nucleocapsid as a mechanism of IRF-3 activation
.
J Virol
76
:
3659
3669
.

Tishon
A
Lewicki
H
Andaya
A
McGavern
D
Martin
L
&
Oldstone
MB
(
2006
)
CD4 T cell control primary measles virus infection of the CNS: regulation is dependent on combined activity with either CD8 T cells or with B cells: CD4, CD8 or B cells alone are ineffective
.
Virology
347
:
234
245
.

Van Binnendijk
RS
van den
HS
van den
KH
Kohl
RH
Woonink
F
Berbers
GA
Conyn-van Spaendonck
MA
&
Kimman
TG
(
2003
)
Evaluation of serological and virological tests in the diagnosis of clinical and subclinical measles virus infections during an outbreak of measles in The Netherlands
.
J Infect Dis
188
:
898
903
.

Vongpunsawad
S
Oezgun
N
Braun
W
&
Cattaneo
R
(
2004
)
Selectively receptor-blind measles viruses: identification of residues necessary for SLAM or CD46-induced fusion and their localization on a new hemagglutinin structural model
.
J Virol
78
:
302
313
.

Wakefield
AJ
Pittilo
RM
Sim
R
Cosby
SL
Stephenson
JR
Dhillon
AP
&
Pounder
RE
(
1993
)
Evidence of persistent measles virus infection in Crohn's disease
.
J Med Virol
39
:
345
353
.

Ward
BJ
Johnson
RT
Vaisberg
A
Jauregui
E
&
Griffin
DE
(
1991
)
Cytokine production in vitro and the lymphoproliferative defect of natural measles virus infection
.
Clin Immunol Immunopathol
61
:
236
248
.

Ward
SV
George
CX
Welch
MJ
Liou
LY
Hahm
B
Lewicki
H
de la Torre
JC
Samuel
CE
&
Oldstone
MB
(
2011
)
RNA editing enzyme adenosine deaminase is a restriction factor for controlling measles virus replication that also is required for embryogenesis
.
P Natl Acad Sci USA
108
:
331
336
.

Wear
DJ
&
Rapp
F
(
1971
)
Latent measles virus infection of the hamster central nervous system
.
J Immunol
107
:
1593
1598
.

Wolfson
LJ
Grais
RF
Luquero
FJ
Birmingham
ME
&
Strebel
PM
(
2009
)
Estimates of measles case fatality ratios: a comprehensive review of community-based studies
.
Int J Epidemiol
38
:
192
205
.

Wong
TC
Ayata
M
Ueda
S
&
Hirano
A
(
1991
)
Role of biased hypermutation in evolution of subacute sclerosing panencephalitis virus from progenitor acute measles virus
.
J Virol
65
:
2191
2199
.

Yanagi
Y
Ono
N
Tatsuo
H
Hashimoto
K
&
Minagawa
H
(
2002
)
Measles virus receptor SLAM (CD150)
.
Virology
299
:
155
161
.

Yanagi
Y
Takeda
M
&
Ohno
S
(
2006
)
Measles virus: cellular receptors, tropism and pathogenesis
.
J Gen Virol
87
:
2767
2779
.

Young
KK
Heineke
BE
&
Wechsler
SL
(
1985
)
M protein instability and lack of H protein processing associated with nonproductive persistent infection of HeLa cells by measles virus
.
Virology
143
:
536
545
.

Yount
JS
Gitlin
L
Moran
TM
&
Lopez
CB
(
2008
)
MDA5 participates in the detection of paramyxovirus infection and is essential for the early activation of dendritic cells in response to Sendai Virus defective interfering particles
.
J Immunol
180
:
4910
4918
.

Yu
XL
Cheng
YM
Shi
BS
et al. (
2008
)
Measles virus infection in adults induces production of IL-10 and is associated with increased CD4+ CD25+ regulatory T cells
.
J Immunol
181
:
7356
7366
.

Zilliox
MJ
Moss
WJ
&
Griffin
DE
(
2007
)
Gene expression changes in peripheral blood mononuclear cells during measles virus infection
.
Clin Vaccine Immunol
14
:
918
923
.

Editor: Ralf Bartenschlager