-
PDF
- Split View
-
Views
-
Cite
Cite
German Rubinstein, Andrea Osswald, Eva Hoster, Marco Losa, Atanaska Elenkova, Sabina Zacharieva, Márcio Carlos Machado, Felicia Alexandra Hanzu, Stephanie Zopp, Katrin Ritzel, Anna Riester, Leah Theresa Braun, Ilonka Kreitschmann-Andermahr, Helen L Storr, Prachi Bansal, María-José Barahona, Elisa Cosaro, Sema Ciftci Dogansen, Philip C Johnston, Ricardo Santos de Oliveira, Christian Raftopoulos, Carla Scaroni, Elena Valassi, Steven J A van der Werff, Jochen Schopohl, Felix Beuschlein, Martin Reincke, Time to Diagnosis in Cushing’s Syndrome: A Meta-Analysis Based on 5367 Patients, The Journal of Clinical Endocrinology & Metabolism, Volume 105, Issue 3, March 2020, Pages e12–e22, https://doi.org/10.1210/clinem/dgz136
- Share Icon Share
Abstract
Signs and symptoms of Cushing’s syndrome (CS) overlap with common diseases, such as the metabolic syndrome, obesity, osteoporosis, and depression. Therefore, it can take years to finally diagnose CS, although early diagnosis is important for prevention of complications.
The aim of this study was to assess the time span between first symptoms and diagnosis of CS in different populations to identify factors associated with an early diagnosis.
A systematic literature search via PubMed was performed to identify studies reporting on time to diagnosis in CS. In addition, unpublished data from patients of our tertiary care center and 4 other centers were included.
Clinical studies reporting on the time to diagnosis of CS were eligible. Corresponding authors were contacted to obtain additional information relevant to the research question.
Data were extracted from the text of the retrieved articles and from additional information provided by authors contacted successfully. From initially 3326 screened studies 44 were included.
Mean time to diagnosis for patients with CS was 34 months (ectopic CS: 14 months; adrenal CS: 30 months; and pituitary CS: 38 months; P < .001). No difference was found for gender, age (<18 and ≥18 years), and year of diagnosis (before and after 2000). Patients with pituitary CS had a longer time to diagnosis in Germany than elsewhere.
Time to diagnosis differs for subtypes of CS but not for gender and age. Time to diagnosis remains to be long and requires to be improved.
Outline
Cushing’s syndrome (CS) is a rare, potentially life-threatening endocrine disease causing, among others, metabolic, psychiatric, musculoskeletal, and cardiovascular comorbidities (1). If left untreated, it is associated with increased mortality, mainly due to cardiovascular and infectious complications, but even in appropriately treated CS, mortality remains elevated (2). CS is mostly adrenocorticotropin (ACTH) dependent, the consequence of corticotroph pituitary adenoma or ectopic ACTH secretion from neuroendocrine tumors. Approximately 20% of cases are ACTH independent due to autonomous cortisol production from adrenal sources. Chronically elevated glucocorticoid concentrations cause the characteristic phenotype, such as weight gain, moon face, buffalo hump, muscle weakness, bruisability, skin atrophy, striae rubrae, menstrual irregularities, hirsutism, acne, and co-morbidities like diabetes mellitus, hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, and osteoporosis (3). Due to the rareness of CS and because these symptoms overlap with other non-CS conditions, it can take many years to diagnose CS in a given patient (4). The recent obesity “epidemic” causes additional challenges to distinguish the few patients with true CS from those with a metabolic syndrome. As the duration of hypercortisolism appears to be the most relevant determinant for the degree of morbidity and preterm mortality, it is important to establish the diagnosis as early as possible (5). Also, there is increasing evidence that restitution of symptoms and body changes after surgery depends on the duration of CS (6). Duration of CS is an important factor influencing patient’s recovery after successful surgery, especially regarding psychiatric morbidity (7), which coincides with changes in brain structure and function sustained during exposure to glucocorticoid excess (8). We hypothesized that the time span from first symptoms to final diagnosis of CS could have changed to the better over time. This could be due to either improved biochemical screening tools for CS or also increasing awareness for rare diseases (9). The aim of this study was to assess the time between first symptoms and diagnosis of CS in different populations and geographic backgrounds and from different decades by performing a systematic literature review and meta-analysis including additional results from the German Cushing’s Registry. We wanted to identify factors that are associated with early or late diagnosis.
Methods and Patients
Study selection
We performed a systematic literature search in PubMed database and Cochrane library according to the Meta-analyses of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (MOOSE) guidelines (10). We used the terms “Cushing’s syndrome,” “Cushing syndrome,” “Cushing’s disease,” “Cushing disease,” and “pituitary ACTH hypersecretion” in the title or abstract to identify published articles reporting on Cushing’s syndrome/disease in general. The literature search was performed in the last week of July 2018.
Inclusion and exclusion criteria
Studies were eligible for analysis when data reporting on time to diagnosis were available as mean time ± standard deviation. Reviews, case reports, guidelines, non-English literature, and nonhuman studies were excluded.
Data extraction
Abstracts were screened carefully by one of the authors (GR) for clinical/patient-based studies. If this was the case, the full-text manuscript was screened for content reporting on time to diagnosis in CS. To obtain data on mean time ± standard deviation for all studies, we contacted the respective corresponding authors of the studies to retrieve missing data. Furthermore, we asked authors to perform additional analysis of their data for different subtypes and gender (if available and possible). Authors of studies published before 2000 were not contacted because of a decreased likelihood to contact successfully.
Munich cohort
We analyzed the data of 172 patients (140 women and 32 men) with all subtypes of CS diagnosed and followed-up at Ludwig-Maximilian-University hospital tertiary care center between 1986 and 2018. Of all patients, 122 had pituitary CS (103 patients diagnosed after 2000), 18 ectopic CS and 32 adrenal CS. The study was performed accordingly to the Declaration of Helsinki. Written consent was given by all study participants.
Definition of the time to diagnosis (onset between first symptom and diagnosis of CS/diagnostic delay)
As in most studies this information was reported rather as a side information, the exact definitions of how the first symptom was defined was mostly not available. In studies with available definition on the first symptom, in general, two different methods were used: either retrospective definition by the patient alone (eg, in a questionnaire) or by defining the first symptoms in a clinical assessment by an endocrinologist.
Definition of variables
We analyzed subtype of CS (pituitary, ectopic, and adrenal and excluding adrenal carcinoma, primary bilateral macronodular adrenal hyperplasia, and primary pigmented nodular adrenocortical disease), sex (female/male), age (children and teenagers <18 years, adults ≥18 years), year of publication (before and after 2000). Analysis of different geographic regions was performed for countries with at least 4 studies available. The analysis for age, year of publication, and geographic regions was done only in patients with pituitary CS due to the imbalance in the number of studies for different subtypes.
Statistical analysis
For statistical analysis of the Munich cohort IBM SPSS Statistics (version 21.0, IBM North America) was used. Metric variables are reported as mean ± standard deviation. Due to the low sample number nonparametric tests were used: Mann–Whitney U test for 2 unpaired groups and the Kruskal–Wallis test with subsequent post hoc analysis for more than 2 unpaired groups. P-values ≤ .05 were considered statistically significant.
For the meta-analysis, forest plots were generated to show mean time to diagnosis along with 95% confidence intervals (CI) for the different studies. To combine data from different studies for meta-analysis, random-effects models were fitted with inverse variance weighting. Mixed-effects models were used to investigate potential effects of different moderators like subtype of CS on time to diagnosis. P-values ≤ .05 were considered statistically significant. Statistical analysis was performed using the robust multiarray average and forest functions of the package metafor (version 2.0) with R version 3.5.0 (www.r-project.org).
Results
Time to diagnosis in the Munich cohort
Time to diagnosis in the Munich cohort was in total 48 ± 51 months. Considering the differential diagnosis, time to diagnosis in patients with adrenal CS was 50 ± 48 months, with ectopic CS 34 ± 52 months and pituitary CS 49 ± 52 months (P = .022). Post hoc analysis showed a significant difference for the mean time to diagnosis for ectopic and adrenal CS (P = .039) and ectopic and pituitary (P = .024) and a nonsignificant difference for adrenal and pituitary CS (P = 1.000). Time to diagnosis in women with CS was 47 ± 49 months, in men with CS 53 ± 61 months (P = .892). Time to diagnosis in 103 patients with pituitary CS diagnosed after 2000 was 52 ± 53 months, in 19 patients with pituitary CS diagnosed before 2000 38 ± 47 months (P = .121). Data are given in mean ± SD.
Included studies
We identified a total of 3325 studies. Seventy-one of these studies contained information on time to diagnosis/duration of symptoms in CS. Six studies were removed due to overlapping or identical patient cohorts. Thirty-four studies presented data as mean time ± standard deviation. Eleven lead authors of these already eligible studies were contacted to get additional information (eg, gender/subtype-related data). The other 31 studies expressed data not as mean time ± standard deviation (eg, median and range or other) and were therefore not eligible. Six studies were published before 2000. We contacted 25 lead authors of these initially not eligible studies to obtain data presented as mean time ± standard deviation. Of all 36 contacted authors, 13 did not respond, 6 responded but could not provide data, and 17 provided additional data. Four of these 17 authors provided us with unpublished data of 1336 patients from their centers (Marco Losa from San Raffaele, University Vita-Salute, Milan, Italy; Atanaska Elenkova from Medical University, Sofia, Bulgaria; Márcio Carlos Machado from Universidade de São Paulo, Brasil; and Felicia Alexandra Hanzu from Hospital Clinic Barcelona, Spain).
In total, data from 44 studies (including our patient cohort) collected between 1969 and 2018 and containing appropriate data on time to diagnosis of 5367 patients were analyzed in this meta-analysis. Studies were heterogeneous regarding subtype of CS, gender, age, and time of recruitment (Table 1; Fig. 1).
Reference . | Year published . | Study type . | Period of time . | Number of patients . | Subtype of CS (Number of patients with subtype) . | Country . | Adults/ children . | Re-Analysis . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Welbourn (11) | 1969 | Retrospective, double- center | 1953–1968 | 45 | Adrenal: 8; Pituitary: 37 | UK | Adults | No |
McArthur (12) | 1979 | Retrospective, single center | 1947–1977 | 27 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Bertagna (13) | 1981 | Retrospective, single center | 1951–1978 | 22 | Adrenal | US | Adults | No |
Hotta (14) | 1985 | Single-Center | N.a. | 8 | Adrenal: 3; Pituitary: 5 | Japan | Adults | No |
Sandler (15) | 1987 | Retrospective, single center | 1959–1982 | 51 | Pituitary | UK | Adults | No |
Magiakou (16) | 1994 | Retrospective, single center | After 1954 | 10 | Ectopic: 1; Pituitary 9 | US | Children | No |
Bochicchio (17) | 1995 | Retrospective, Multi-Center | 1975–1990 | 668 | Pituitary | Europe | Adults | No |
Magiakou (18) | 1997 | Single-Center | N.a. | 31 | All (Adr: 5; Ect: 3; Pit: 23) | US | Children | No |
Massoud (19) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1982 | 12 | Pituitary | UK | Children | No |
Robyn (20) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | 1976–1996 | 6 | Pituitary | Australia | Children | No |
Invitti (21) | 1998 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 1978 | 393 | All (Adr: 80; Ect: 25; Pit: 288) | Italy | Adults | No |
Selvais (22) | 1998 | Retrospective, single center | 1990–1996 | 21 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | No |
Flitsch (23) | 2000 | Prospective, Single-Center | N.a. | 19 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Vella (24) | 2001 | Retrospective, single center | 1996–2001 | 16 | Ectopic: 4; Pituitary: 12 | US | Adults | No |
Faggiano (25) | 2003 | Prospective, single-center | N.a. | 25 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Giraldi (26) | 2003 | Retrospective, multicentric | N.a. | 280 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Johansson (27) | 2004 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1964 | 15 | Pituitary | Sweden | Adults | No |
Salgado (28) | 2006 | Retrospective, single-center | 1975–2005 | 25 | Ectopic | Brazil | Adults | No |
Bhansali (29) | 2007 | Retrospective, single-center | 1985–2006 | 12 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Barahona (30) | 2009 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1982 | 55 | Adrenal: 11; Pituitary: 44) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Oliveira (31) | 2010 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2006 | 15 | Pituitary | Brazil | Children | Yes |
Bolland (32) | 2011 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1960–2005 | 253 | All (Adr: 45; Ect: 15; Pit: 167; 26 with missing data) | New Zealand | Adults | Yes |
Psaras (33) | 2011 | Retrospective, single-center | 1998–2007 | 33 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Valassi (34) | 2011 | Retrospective, from 2008 prospective, multicentric | Since 2000 | 420 | All (Adr: 107; Ect: 22; Pit: 291) | Europe | Adults | Yes |
Lodish (35) | 2012 | Retrospective, Single-center | 1997–2007 | 57 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Lonser (36) | 2013 | Prospective, single-center | 1982–2010 | 200 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Van der Werff (37) | 2014 | Single-center | N.a. | 22 | Pituitary | Netherlands | Adults | Yes |
Zilio (38) | 2014 | Retrospective, single-center | 2002–2010 | 84 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Aranda (39) | 2015 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, Single-center | 1974–2011 | 67 | All (Adr: 8; Ect: 2; Pit: 57) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Ghazi (40) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1985 | 15 | Ectopic | Iran | Adults | No |
Kreitschmann-Andermahr (41) | 2015 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 2005 | 176 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | Yes |
Zielinski (42) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | 2000–2005 | 10 | Pituitary | Poland | Adults | No |
Geer (43) | 2016 | Prospective, Single-center | N.a. | 30 | Pituitary | US | Adults | No |
Machado (44) | 2016 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2014 | 421 | Ectopic: 49; Pituitary: 37 | Brazil | Adults | Yes |
Shapiro (45) | 2016 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2014 | 39 | Pituitary | UK | Children | Yes |
Bansal (46) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 1987–2015 | 230 | Pituitary | India | Adults | Yes |
Davi (47) | 2017 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1986–2014 | 110 | Ectopic | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Johnston (48) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 2004- 2013 | 101 | Pituitary | USA | Adults | Yes |
Sathyakumar (49) | 2017 | Retrospective | 2006–2015 | 21 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Brichard (50) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | 1997–2017 | 71 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | Yes |
Dogansen (51) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 2007 | 35 | All (Adr: 15; Ect: 3; Pit: 17) | Turkey | Adults | Yes |
Elenkova | Unpublished, contact based on (52) | Retrospective, single-center | 1968–2018 | 520 | All (Adr: 159; Ect: 13; Pit: 348) | Bulgaria | Adults | Yes |
Losa | Unpublished, contact based on (53) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2017 | 624 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Rubinstein | Unpublished (own data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1986–2018 | 172 | All (Adr: 32; Ect: 18; Pit: 122) | Germany | Adults |
Reference . | Year published . | Study type . | Period of time . | Number of patients . | Subtype of CS (Number of patients with subtype) . | Country . | Adults/ children . | Re-Analysis . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Welbourn (11) | 1969 | Retrospective, double- center | 1953–1968 | 45 | Adrenal: 8; Pituitary: 37 | UK | Adults | No |
McArthur (12) | 1979 | Retrospective, single center | 1947–1977 | 27 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Bertagna (13) | 1981 | Retrospective, single center | 1951–1978 | 22 | Adrenal | US | Adults | No |
Hotta (14) | 1985 | Single-Center | N.a. | 8 | Adrenal: 3; Pituitary: 5 | Japan | Adults | No |
Sandler (15) | 1987 | Retrospective, single center | 1959–1982 | 51 | Pituitary | UK | Adults | No |
Magiakou (16) | 1994 | Retrospective, single center | After 1954 | 10 | Ectopic: 1; Pituitary 9 | US | Children | No |
Bochicchio (17) | 1995 | Retrospective, Multi-Center | 1975–1990 | 668 | Pituitary | Europe | Adults | No |
Magiakou (18) | 1997 | Single-Center | N.a. | 31 | All (Adr: 5; Ect: 3; Pit: 23) | US | Children | No |
Massoud (19) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1982 | 12 | Pituitary | UK | Children | No |
Robyn (20) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | 1976–1996 | 6 | Pituitary | Australia | Children | No |
Invitti (21) | 1998 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 1978 | 393 | All (Adr: 80; Ect: 25; Pit: 288) | Italy | Adults | No |
Selvais (22) | 1998 | Retrospective, single center | 1990–1996 | 21 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | No |
Flitsch (23) | 2000 | Prospective, Single-Center | N.a. | 19 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Vella (24) | 2001 | Retrospective, single center | 1996–2001 | 16 | Ectopic: 4; Pituitary: 12 | US | Adults | No |
Faggiano (25) | 2003 | Prospective, single-center | N.a. | 25 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Giraldi (26) | 2003 | Retrospective, multicentric | N.a. | 280 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Johansson (27) | 2004 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1964 | 15 | Pituitary | Sweden | Adults | No |
Salgado (28) | 2006 | Retrospective, single-center | 1975–2005 | 25 | Ectopic | Brazil | Adults | No |
Bhansali (29) | 2007 | Retrospective, single-center | 1985–2006 | 12 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Barahona (30) | 2009 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1982 | 55 | Adrenal: 11; Pituitary: 44) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Oliveira (31) | 2010 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2006 | 15 | Pituitary | Brazil | Children | Yes |
Bolland (32) | 2011 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1960–2005 | 253 | All (Adr: 45; Ect: 15; Pit: 167; 26 with missing data) | New Zealand | Adults | Yes |
Psaras (33) | 2011 | Retrospective, single-center | 1998–2007 | 33 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Valassi (34) | 2011 | Retrospective, from 2008 prospective, multicentric | Since 2000 | 420 | All (Adr: 107; Ect: 22; Pit: 291) | Europe | Adults | Yes |
Lodish (35) | 2012 | Retrospective, Single-center | 1997–2007 | 57 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Lonser (36) | 2013 | Prospective, single-center | 1982–2010 | 200 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Van der Werff (37) | 2014 | Single-center | N.a. | 22 | Pituitary | Netherlands | Adults | Yes |
Zilio (38) | 2014 | Retrospective, single-center | 2002–2010 | 84 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Aranda (39) | 2015 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, Single-center | 1974–2011 | 67 | All (Adr: 8; Ect: 2; Pit: 57) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Ghazi (40) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1985 | 15 | Ectopic | Iran | Adults | No |
Kreitschmann-Andermahr (41) | 2015 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 2005 | 176 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | Yes |
Zielinski (42) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | 2000–2005 | 10 | Pituitary | Poland | Adults | No |
Geer (43) | 2016 | Prospective, Single-center | N.a. | 30 | Pituitary | US | Adults | No |
Machado (44) | 2016 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2014 | 421 | Ectopic: 49; Pituitary: 37 | Brazil | Adults | Yes |
Shapiro (45) | 2016 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2014 | 39 | Pituitary | UK | Children | Yes |
Bansal (46) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 1987–2015 | 230 | Pituitary | India | Adults | Yes |
Davi (47) | 2017 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1986–2014 | 110 | Ectopic | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Johnston (48) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 2004- 2013 | 101 | Pituitary | USA | Adults | Yes |
Sathyakumar (49) | 2017 | Retrospective | 2006–2015 | 21 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Brichard (50) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | 1997–2017 | 71 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | Yes |
Dogansen (51) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 2007 | 35 | All (Adr: 15; Ect: 3; Pit: 17) | Turkey | Adults | Yes |
Elenkova | Unpublished, contact based on (52) | Retrospective, single-center | 1968–2018 | 520 | All (Adr: 159; Ect: 13; Pit: 348) | Bulgaria | Adults | Yes |
Losa | Unpublished, contact based on (53) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2017 | 624 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Rubinstein | Unpublished (own data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1986–2018 | 172 | All (Adr: 32; Ect: 18; Pit: 122) | Germany | Adults |
Abbreviations: Adr, adrenal; Ect, ectopic; N.a., not available; Pit, pituitary.
Reference . | Year published . | Study type . | Period of time . | Number of patients . | Subtype of CS (Number of patients with subtype) . | Country . | Adults/ children . | Re-Analysis . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Welbourn (11) | 1969 | Retrospective, double- center | 1953–1968 | 45 | Adrenal: 8; Pituitary: 37 | UK | Adults | No |
McArthur (12) | 1979 | Retrospective, single center | 1947–1977 | 27 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Bertagna (13) | 1981 | Retrospective, single center | 1951–1978 | 22 | Adrenal | US | Adults | No |
Hotta (14) | 1985 | Single-Center | N.a. | 8 | Adrenal: 3; Pituitary: 5 | Japan | Adults | No |
Sandler (15) | 1987 | Retrospective, single center | 1959–1982 | 51 | Pituitary | UK | Adults | No |
Magiakou (16) | 1994 | Retrospective, single center | After 1954 | 10 | Ectopic: 1; Pituitary 9 | US | Children | No |
Bochicchio (17) | 1995 | Retrospective, Multi-Center | 1975–1990 | 668 | Pituitary | Europe | Adults | No |
Magiakou (18) | 1997 | Single-Center | N.a. | 31 | All (Adr: 5; Ect: 3; Pit: 23) | US | Children | No |
Massoud (19) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1982 | 12 | Pituitary | UK | Children | No |
Robyn (20) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | 1976–1996 | 6 | Pituitary | Australia | Children | No |
Invitti (21) | 1998 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 1978 | 393 | All (Adr: 80; Ect: 25; Pit: 288) | Italy | Adults | No |
Selvais (22) | 1998 | Retrospective, single center | 1990–1996 | 21 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | No |
Flitsch (23) | 2000 | Prospective, Single-Center | N.a. | 19 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Vella (24) | 2001 | Retrospective, single center | 1996–2001 | 16 | Ectopic: 4; Pituitary: 12 | US | Adults | No |
Faggiano (25) | 2003 | Prospective, single-center | N.a. | 25 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Giraldi (26) | 2003 | Retrospective, multicentric | N.a. | 280 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Johansson (27) | 2004 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1964 | 15 | Pituitary | Sweden | Adults | No |
Salgado (28) | 2006 | Retrospective, single-center | 1975–2005 | 25 | Ectopic | Brazil | Adults | No |
Bhansali (29) | 2007 | Retrospective, single-center | 1985–2006 | 12 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Barahona (30) | 2009 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1982 | 55 | Adrenal: 11; Pituitary: 44) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Oliveira (31) | 2010 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2006 | 15 | Pituitary | Brazil | Children | Yes |
Bolland (32) | 2011 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1960–2005 | 253 | All (Adr: 45; Ect: 15; Pit: 167; 26 with missing data) | New Zealand | Adults | Yes |
Psaras (33) | 2011 | Retrospective, single-center | 1998–2007 | 33 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Valassi (34) | 2011 | Retrospective, from 2008 prospective, multicentric | Since 2000 | 420 | All (Adr: 107; Ect: 22; Pit: 291) | Europe | Adults | Yes |
Lodish (35) | 2012 | Retrospective, Single-center | 1997–2007 | 57 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Lonser (36) | 2013 | Prospective, single-center | 1982–2010 | 200 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Van der Werff (37) | 2014 | Single-center | N.a. | 22 | Pituitary | Netherlands | Adults | Yes |
Zilio (38) | 2014 | Retrospective, single-center | 2002–2010 | 84 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Aranda (39) | 2015 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, Single-center | 1974–2011 | 67 | All (Adr: 8; Ect: 2; Pit: 57) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Ghazi (40) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1985 | 15 | Ectopic | Iran | Adults | No |
Kreitschmann-Andermahr (41) | 2015 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 2005 | 176 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | Yes |
Zielinski (42) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | 2000–2005 | 10 | Pituitary | Poland | Adults | No |
Geer (43) | 2016 | Prospective, Single-center | N.a. | 30 | Pituitary | US | Adults | No |
Machado (44) | 2016 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2014 | 421 | Ectopic: 49; Pituitary: 37 | Brazil | Adults | Yes |
Shapiro (45) | 2016 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2014 | 39 | Pituitary | UK | Children | Yes |
Bansal (46) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 1987–2015 | 230 | Pituitary | India | Adults | Yes |
Davi (47) | 2017 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1986–2014 | 110 | Ectopic | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Johnston (48) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 2004- 2013 | 101 | Pituitary | USA | Adults | Yes |
Sathyakumar (49) | 2017 | Retrospective | 2006–2015 | 21 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Brichard (50) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | 1997–2017 | 71 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | Yes |
Dogansen (51) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 2007 | 35 | All (Adr: 15; Ect: 3; Pit: 17) | Turkey | Adults | Yes |
Elenkova | Unpublished, contact based on (52) | Retrospective, single-center | 1968–2018 | 520 | All (Adr: 159; Ect: 13; Pit: 348) | Bulgaria | Adults | Yes |
Losa | Unpublished, contact based on (53) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2017 | 624 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Rubinstein | Unpublished (own data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1986–2018 | 172 | All (Adr: 32; Ect: 18; Pit: 122) | Germany | Adults |
Reference . | Year published . | Study type . | Period of time . | Number of patients . | Subtype of CS (Number of patients with subtype) . | Country . | Adults/ children . | Re-Analysis . |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Welbourn (11) | 1969 | Retrospective, double- center | 1953–1968 | 45 | Adrenal: 8; Pituitary: 37 | UK | Adults | No |
McArthur (12) | 1979 | Retrospective, single center | 1947–1977 | 27 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Bertagna (13) | 1981 | Retrospective, single center | 1951–1978 | 22 | Adrenal | US | Adults | No |
Hotta (14) | 1985 | Single-Center | N.a. | 8 | Adrenal: 3; Pituitary: 5 | Japan | Adults | No |
Sandler (15) | 1987 | Retrospective, single center | 1959–1982 | 51 | Pituitary | UK | Adults | No |
Magiakou (16) | 1994 | Retrospective, single center | After 1954 | 10 | Ectopic: 1; Pituitary 9 | US | Children | No |
Bochicchio (17) | 1995 | Retrospective, Multi-Center | 1975–1990 | 668 | Pituitary | Europe | Adults | No |
Magiakou (18) | 1997 | Single-Center | N.a. | 31 | All (Adr: 5; Ect: 3; Pit: 23) | US | Children | No |
Massoud (19) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1982 | 12 | Pituitary | UK | Children | No |
Robyn (20) | 1997 | Retrospective, single center | 1976–1996 | 6 | Pituitary | Australia | Children | No |
Invitti (21) | 1998 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 1978 | 393 | All (Adr: 80; Ect: 25; Pit: 288) | Italy | Adults | No |
Selvais (22) | 1998 | Retrospective, single center | 1990–1996 | 21 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | No |
Flitsch (23) | 2000 | Prospective, Single-Center | N.a. | 19 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Vella (24) | 2001 | Retrospective, single center | 1996–2001 | 16 | Ectopic: 4; Pituitary: 12 | US | Adults | No |
Faggiano (25) | 2003 | Prospective, single-center | N.a. | 25 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Giraldi (26) | 2003 | Retrospective, multicentric | N.a. | 280 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | No |
Johansson (27) | 2004 | Retrospective, single center | Since 1964 | 15 | Pituitary | Sweden | Adults | No |
Salgado (28) | 2006 | Retrospective, single-center | 1975–2005 | 25 | Ectopic | Brazil | Adults | No |
Bhansali (29) | 2007 | Retrospective, single-center | 1985–2006 | 12 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Barahona (30) | 2009 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1982 | 55 | Adrenal: 11; Pituitary: 44) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Oliveira (31) | 2010 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2006 | 15 | Pituitary | Brazil | Children | Yes |
Bolland (32) | 2011 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1960–2005 | 253 | All (Adr: 45; Ect: 15; Pit: 167; 26 with missing data) | New Zealand | Adults | Yes |
Psaras (33) | 2011 | Retrospective, single-center | 1998–2007 | 33 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | No |
Valassi (34) | 2011 | Retrospective, from 2008 prospective, multicentric | Since 2000 | 420 | All (Adr: 107; Ect: 22; Pit: 291) | Europe | Adults | Yes |
Lodish (35) | 2012 | Retrospective, Single-center | 1997–2007 | 57 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Lonser (36) | 2013 | Prospective, single-center | 1982–2010 | 200 | Pituitary | US | Children | No |
Van der Werff (37) | 2014 | Single-center | N.a. | 22 | Pituitary | Netherlands | Adults | Yes |
Zilio (38) | 2014 | Retrospective, single-center | 2002–2010 | 84 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Aranda (39) | 2015 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, Single-center | 1974–2011 | 67 | All (Adr: 8; Ect: 2; Pit: 57) | Spain | Adults | Yes |
Ghazi (40) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 1985 | 15 | Ectopic | Iran | Adults | No |
Kreitschmann-Andermahr (41) | 2015 | Retrospective, multicentric | Since 2005 | 176 | Pituitary | Germany | Adults | Yes |
Zielinski (42) | 2015 | Retrospective, single-center | 2000–2005 | 10 | Pituitary | Poland | Adults | No |
Geer (43) | 2016 | Prospective, Single-center | N.a. | 30 | Pituitary | US | Adults | No |
Machado (44) | 2016 (and unpublished data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2014 | 421 | Ectopic: 49; Pituitary: 37 | Brazil | Adults | Yes |
Shapiro (45) | 2016 | Retrospective, single-center | 1982–2014 | 39 | Pituitary | UK | Children | Yes |
Bansal (46) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 1987–2015 | 230 | Pituitary | India | Adults | Yes |
Davi (47) | 2017 | Retrospective, multicentric | 1986–2014 | 110 | Ectopic | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Johnston (48) | 2017 | Retrospective, single-center | 2004- 2013 | 101 | Pituitary | USA | Adults | Yes |
Sathyakumar (49) | 2017 | Retrospective | 2006–2015 | 21 | Ectopic | India | Adults | No |
Brichard (50) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | 1997–2017 | 71 | Pituitary | Belgium | Adults | Yes |
Dogansen (51) | 2018 | Retrospective, single-center | Since 2007 | 35 | All (Adr: 15; Ect: 3; Pit: 17) | Turkey | Adults | Yes |
Elenkova | Unpublished, contact based on (52) | Retrospective, single-center | 1968–2018 | 520 | All (Adr: 159; Ect: 13; Pit: 348) | Bulgaria | Adults | Yes |
Losa | Unpublished, contact based on (53) | Retrospective, single-center | 1990–2017 | 624 | Pituitary | Italy | Adults | Yes |
Rubinstein | Unpublished (own data) | Retrospective, single-center | 1986–2018 | 172 | All (Adr: 32; Ect: 18; Pit: 122) | Germany | Adults |
Abbreviations: Adr, adrenal; Ect, ectopic; N.a., not available; Pit, pituitary.

Time to diagnosis according to subtype
Meta-analysis of all included studies showed a mean time to diagnosis of 34 months (95% CI 30–38) without stratifying for subtypes, gender, age, recruitment time, and geographical background (Fig. 1 in (54)). Among the studies stratifying for CS subtypes, mean time to diagnosis was 30 months (95% CI 24–36) in adrenal CS, 14 months (95% CI 11–17) in ectopic CS, and 38 months (95% CI 33–43) in pituitary CS (P < .001). Post hoc analysis showed a significant difference for the mean time to diagnosis for ectopic and adrenal CS (P = .0025), ectopic and pituitary (P < .0001) and a nonsignificant trend for adrenal and pituitary CS (P = .098) (Fig. 2). The majority of patients with ectopic CS had bronchial or thymic carcinoids, some gastroenteropancreatic neuroendocrine tumors. Small cell lung carcinomas were present in 0% to 27% of the series, with the largest series compromising 110 of which 4% had small cell lung carcinomas.

Mean time to diagnosis according to subtype (adrenal, ectopic, pituitary).
Impact of sex
Overall, mean time to diagnosis in female patients with CS (all subtypes) was 33 months (95% CI 27–38) compared to 31 months (95% CI 26–36) in males (P = .66) (Fig. 2 in (54)), with similar distribution according to subtypes in both sexes.
Time to diagnosis according to age in pituitary CS
We hypothesized that mean time to diagnosis might be shorter in pediatric CS (age <18) than in adults because of the typical growth retardation observed in the former. However, in the 9 pediatric studies, mean time was 33 months (95% CI 29–38) versus 39 months (95% CI 33–45) in adult patients (P = .37) (Fig. 3 in (54)).
Impact of the year of publication on the time to diagnosis in pituitary CS
We further wondered whether the publication year of the study might have impact on time to diagnosis. Based on the assumption that secular trends in disease awareness, improved diagnostic tools and phenotypic presentation might influence the speed in identifying CS, we chose the year 2000 as a cut-off. Surprisingly, studies published before 2000 had an identical latency (37 months, 95% CI 29–46) with the studies published after 2000 (37 months, 95% CI 31–44; P = 0.92) (Fig. 4 in (54)).
Time to diagnosis in pituitary CS according to geographic regions
Due to the fact that studies from all over the world were included, we wondered whether differences in the mean time to diagnosis in the largest subgroup of patients with pituitary CS could be identified. Countries with at least 4 studies available were Germany, Italy, United Kingdom, and the United States.
Mean time to diagnosis was 34 months (95% CI 29–40) for United States, 35 months (95% CI 26–45) for Italy, 39 months (95% CI 27–51) for United Kingdom, and 56 months (95% CI 43–68) for Germany (P = .02). Post hoc analysis showed significant differences for the mean time to diagnosis between Germany and United States (P = .0038), Italy (P = 0.0052) and United Kingdom (P = 0.039) and nonsignificant differences for other comparison (Fig. 3; Table 2).

Mean time to diagnosis according to region in pituitary Cushing’s syndrome (Germany, Italy, United Kingdom, United States).
Post-hoc analysis with P-values for the time to diagnosis in pituitary Cushing’s syndrome according to geographic regions
. | Germany . | Italy . | United Kingdom . | United States . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Germany | X | .0052 | .039 | .0038 |
Italy | .0052 | X | .61 | .96 |
United Kingdom | .039 | .61 | X | .57 |
United States | .0038 | .96 | .57 | X |
. | Germany . | Italy . | United Kingdom . | United States . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Germany | X | .0052 | .039 | .0038 |
Italy | .0052 | X | .61 | .96 |
United Kingdom | .039 | .61 | X | .57 |
United States | .0038 | .96 | .57 | X |
Post-hoc analysis with P-values for the time to diagnosis in pituitary Cushing’s syndrome according to geographic regions
. | Germany . | Italy . | United Kingdom . | United States . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Germany | X | .0052 | .039 | .0038 |
Italy | .0052 | X | .61 | .96 |
United Kingdom | .039 | .61 | X | .57 |
United States | .0038 | .96 | .57 | X |
. | Germany . | Italy . | United Kingdom . | United States . |
---|---|---|---|---|
Germany | X | .0052 | .039 | .0038 |
Italy | .0052 | X | .61 | .96 |
United Kingdom | .039 | .61 | X | .57 |
United States | .0038 | .96 | .57 | X |
Discussion
We report here the meta-analysis of the time to diagnosis from 44 studies, to which our own unpublished series was added. The results of our own cohort is in line with the results after statistical analysis of all the pooled studies.
We herein demonstrate that the mean time to diagnosis of CS is, in general, 34 months. Patients with ectopic CS had a significantly shorter time to diagnosis than patients with adrenal and pituitary CS. Patients with adrenal CS have a trend to shorter time to diagnosis than patients with pituitary CS without reaching statistical significance. It seems reasonable to speculate that ectopic CS due to aggressive ACTH-producing tumors is associated with a more severe clinical phenotype developing much more rapidly and causing more life-threatening complications (including severe hypokalemia and hyperglycemia) (55), even though only a minority of patients in our meta-analysis had small cell lung cancer, an entity with a particular aggressive clinical phenotype.
The nonsignificant difference in the time to diagnosis between adrenal and pituitary CS is not fully understood. This finding contrasts with the significantly faster recovery of adrenal insufficiency in pituitary CS compared to adrenal CS (56), which would rather imply a longer duration of hypercortisolism and time to diagnosis in adrenal CS. The more complicated biochemical testing and tumor localization (eg, sinus petrosus catheterization) in pituitary CS compared to the usually rather straight forward diagnostic work-up in adrenal CS might be a possible explanation to this fact.
On the other hand, the longer exposure to high glucocorticoid levels in pituitary CS could contribute to the fact that patients with pituitary CS have significantly lower disease-specific quality of life (CushingQoL) scores compared to patients with adrenal CS (57). Together with the risk of recurrence and pituitary deficiency, it can explain the increased long-term emotional instability observed in this subtype. This underscores the necessity of careful screening for psychiatric comorbidities in every Cushing patient. In addition, psychological counseling by health-care professionals should be part of every Cushing clinic (58).
Gender does not seem to have a relevant impact on the time to diagnosis. It confirms the results of Kreitschmann-Andermahr and colleagues, who did not find a difference in the overall diagnostic delay between females and males. These authors, however, showed that females contacted physicians earlier than males whereas in male patients, the physician was the one recognizing symptoms of CS (41).
Surprisingly, we did not identify significant differences in time to diagnosis according to age in pediatric CD versus adult CD (33 vs. 39 months, P = .37). This is unexpected since hypercortisolism in children comes with severe growth retardation, a feature that is difficult to overlook. In addition, children with CD gain weight, which makes CD the only condition in pediatrics where curves for height and weight on the growth chart deviate in different directions.
In addition, we did not identify a trend toward earlier diagnosis in more recently treated patients in comparison to studies published before 2000. We explain this by a higher prevalence of advanced obesity nowadays, which, besides the obvious weight gain, is the condition with the most overlapping symptoms with CS (moon facies, diabetes mellitus, hypertension, menstrual irregularities). In our experience, patients with confirmed CS in fact have a lower body mass index compared to patients with suspected, but biochemically not confirmed CS (~30kg/m2 vs. 33 kg/m2; unpublished data). Therefore, it is good clinical practice that primarily not obesity, but the presence of unusual features for age (such as osteoporosis or hypertension), multiple progressive features, and signs and symptoms of protein catabolism (ie, myopathy) should rise the suspicion for CS (3, 4). A diagnostic score of clinical variables predicting diagnosis of CS could be useful in this clinical situation (59).
Novel diagnostic approaches such as automatic face recognition using computerized techniques were thought to be useful in early recognition of body changes but have lately turned out to be of limited value (60).
Strengths and limitations
We were able to include a large body of studies and obtain additional data for those studies in which the data format was not appropriate. This makes this study the largest ever published on this subject. Most of the limitations are inherent to this type of meta-analysis. A relevant limitation is the fact that in most of the included publications the information about time to diagnosis/diagnostic delay was not the primary endpoint of the study. In such a scenario, there is almost always a lack of a definition of how the first symptom was defined. Moreover, when it was described, different methods and definitions were used to assess the first symptoms: Some authors used questionnaires to retrospectively assess first symptoms, whereas other authors defined first symptom related to CS by clinical assessment by an endocrinologist. As cognitive deficits and emotional disturbances may be present in patients with CS their definitions might not be accurate. In summary, different definitions and perspectives (patients/physicians) were used to assess the time from first symptom to final diagnosis, which might have led to rather strict (with a shorter time to diagnosis) or permissive (longer time to diagnosis) definitions. We nevertheless think that this applies to all studies and did not change over time. In addition, as estimates for time to diagnosis were not the primary endpoints of the studies, publication bias seems rather unlikely for this meta-analysis.
Different definitions of first symptom of CS might be also an explanation why time to diagnosis varied in different geographic regions. For example, the estimation of the first symptom related to CS in 3 of the 4 studies conducted in Germany were made by the patients themselves, which could explain the rather long time to diagnosis due to the cognitive and emotional impairment.
In summary, the main finding of our study is 2-fold: first, there is a clear difference in the time to diagnosis depending on the subtype of CS, being shortest in ectopic CS; second, despite a multitude of improvements in the care of patients, we did not detect secular trends toward earlier diagnosis in pediatric patients or patients with more recent diagnosis. Although there may be methodical limitations to our meta-analysis, this is clearly disappointing from both patients and physicians perspectives.
It remains unclear how to shorten the time to diagnosis in CS. Patients with rare diseases in general and CS in particular face the problem of a delayed diagnosis. At the same time, CS is often wrongly suspected in cohorts with a low pretest probability (such as obesity).
On the other hand, published data and our own experience have shown that the prevalence of Cushing’s syndrome is significantly higher among patients with uncontrolled diabetes mellitus and arterial hypertension, adrenal incidentalomas, and osteoporosis (4). Consequently, these common diseases, especially when occurring together, may be subject to a preselection in the process of targeted search for this rare pathology especially in young patients.
In our opinion it seems unlikely to educate nonendocrinologists on symptoms of CS. More effective measures could be to educate nonendocrine specialists and general practitioners in pattern recognition: unusual presentations and dynamic developments (multiple progressive features especially of catabolic effects from hypercortisolism such as myopathy and skin atrophy) apply to many rare diseases and might be better discriminants for diagnosis.
In addition, there is a high need for simple and effective biochemical screening approaches (61). Current tests have significant sensitivity and specificity issues. Recently we showed that a 7-steroid fingerprint from baseline plasma samples could nicely separate CS from rule-out CS. This study stokes the hope that such a test (if validated) could be superior to currently used standard Cushing screening tests (62).
Acknowledgments
We thank Mark Bolland for providing us with additional data and his input on this manuscript.
Financial Summary: This work is part of the German Cushing’s Registry CUSTODES and has been supported by a grant from the Else Kröner-Fresenius Stiftung to MR (2012_A103 and 2015_A228). Additionally, AR, FB, and MR received funding by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) Projektnummer: 314061271-TRR 205.
Additional Information
Disclosure Summary: The authors have nothing to disclose.
Data Availability: All data generated or analyzed during this study are included in this published article or in the data repositories listed in References.
References