We describe a new approach to calculating photon trajectories and gravitational lensing effects in the strong gravitational field of the Kerr black hole. These techniques are applied to explore both the imaging and spectral properties of photons emitted from an accretion disc, which perform multiple orbits of the central mass before escaping to infinity. Viewed at large inclinations, these higher-order photons contribute ∼20 per cent of the total luminosity of the system for a Schwarzschild hole, while for an extreme Kerr black hole this fraction rises to ∼60 per cent. In more realistic models, these photons will be reabsorbed by the disc at large distances from the hole, but this returning radiation could provide a physical mechanism to resolve the discrepancy between the predicted and observed optical/ultraviolet colours in active galactic nuclei. Conversely, at low inclinations, higher-order images reintercept the disc plane close to the black hole, so need not be absorbed by the disc if this is within the plunging region. These photons form a bright ring carrying approximately 10 per cent of the total disc luminosity for a Schwarzschild black hole. The spatial separation between the inner edge of the disc and the ring is similar to the size of the event horizon. This is resolvable for supermassive black holes with proposed X-ray interferometery missions such as the Microarcsecond X-ray Imaging Mission (MAXIM), and so has the potential to provide an observational test of strong field gravity.
Calculations of the relativistic corrections to photon properties have been ongoing for nearly three decades, starting with the classic work of Cunningham (1975), who calculated the distortions expected on the spectrum of a geometrically thin, optically thick, Keplerian accretion disc orbiting a Kerr black hole. Interest in these calculations dramatically increased with the realization that the accretion disc could emit line as well as continuum radiation. Iron Kα fluorescence resulting from X-ray irradiation of the accretion disc can give a narrow feature, on which the relativistic distortions are much more easily measured than on the broad accretion disc continuum (Fabian et al. 1989). Since then, several groups have developed numerical codes that are capable of determining these effects both for standard discs (Dovčiak, Karas & Yaqoob 2004, and references therein) and alternative emission geometries, such as optically thin discs (Bursa et al. 2004).
While the problem is well defined, there are many technical and numerical issues which arise in calculating the effects of strong gravity. Light bending can result in lensing which strongly amplifies the emission, so a very small area of the accretion flow can make a large contribution on the observed flux. Here we describe how to efficiently calculate the effects of strong light bending, and we illustrate the effectiveness of this approach by using the code to compute the most extreme light bending possible, the higher-order images and spectra of an accretion disc (Viergutz 1993; Bao, Hadrava & Ostgaard 1994; Cadez, Fanton & Calvani 1998). The first-order image is from photons from the underside of the disc, which are bent back into the observer's line of sight, while second-order images are produced by photons from the upper side of the disc, which complete a full orbit around the black hole before reaching the observer. Obviously such paths must cross the equatorial plane, so are likely to reintercept the disc. For an optically thick disc, then, this returning radiation adds to the intrinsic disc emission, and can enhance the emissivity at small radii for extreme Kerr black holes, although it has little effect for Schwarzschild black holes (Cunningham 1976; Laor, Netzer & Piran 1990; Agol & Krolik 2000).
None the less, the first-order image of the disc can dominate the flux at high inclinations if the optically thick disc has rather limited radial extent. Even if it does not, some of the higher-order image flux can escape to the observer through the inner ‘hole’ in the disc below the radius of the minimum stable orbit, assuming that the plunging region is optically thin (but see Reynolds & Begelman 1997). The fraction escaping through this inner ‘hole’ is rather larger for Schwarzschild than for Kerr black holes, as the size of the gap between the innermost stable orbit and horizon is larger for the non-spinning black hole. Obviously, such paths are exquisitely sensitive to the gravitational potential, being close to the true photon orbit point, which is the (unstable) crossover between capture by the black hole and escape to infinity. This makes them potentially an excellent test of strong gravity, and they could be observable in nearby luminous active galactic nuclei (AGNs) with μarcsec imaging X-ray interferometers such as the Microarcsecond X-ray Imaging Mission (MAXIM; Gendreau et al. 2001).
Such instruments could also observe the spin of a nearby supermassive black hole simply from the size of the direct image (Fukue 2003; Takahashi 2004), assuming that the mass and distance are known. A disc down to the last stable orbit extends down to 6rg in a Schwarzschild black hole but only 1.23rg in a maximal Kerr black hole (a = 0.998). Light bending is stronger in Kerr than in Schwarzschild black holes, but the apparent size of the ‘hole’ in the disc still changes by a factor of ∼3. This contrasts with the case where the accretion flow has emission down below the last stable orbit, where the size of the true black hole shadow is rather similar for both Schwarzschild and Kerr black holes (Falcke, Melia & Agol 2000; Takahashi 2004). Observations of the galactic black hole binaries support the idea that there is a disc down to the minimum stable orbit in certain, fairly high luminosity spectral states (Ebisawa et al. 1993; Kubota et al. 1999; Gierliński & Done 2004). However, at lower luminosities this is probably replaced by a more complex accretion flow which may have continuous energy release down to the horizon (Narayan & Yi 1995; Agol & Krolik 2000; Krolik & Hawley 2002; Afshordi & Paczyński 2003). While the stellar remnant black holes require nanoarcsec imaging to resolve, nearby luminous AGNs also should have a ‘hole’ in the disc from the minimum stable orbit, which is accessible to MAXIM.
The paper is split into two parts. In Section 2 we introduce the relevant theory necessary to perform efficient calculation of photon properties in strong gravity, including a review of the properties of the effective potentials governing photon motion. In Section 3, we apply these techniques to examine the contribution of orbiting photons to the standard accretion disc solution through images of the inner region of the accretion flow, generation of fluorescent iron Kα line profiles and the relative roles played by the different types of photon paths. Readers not interested in technical details should go straight to Section 3.
Calculating Photon Paths in Strong Gravity
Null geodesic equations
Material in an accretion flow near to a black hole emits radiation, which is received by a (possibly distant) observer. These photons enable the observer to form an image of the flow, which in turn determines the measured spectral properties (Beckwith & Done 2004). In the geometric optics approximation, the photons follow null geodesics, which in the Kerr metric (written in Boyer—Lindquist coordinates with G = M = c = 1) are described by (Chandrasekhar 1983)Viergutz 1993): Chandrasekhar 1983; de Felice & Preti 1999). The Kerr metric is both stationary and axisymmetric, so the derived set of geodesic equations (1) are independent of both of the coordinates t and φ. The properties of a given geodesic path (specified by a λ, q pair) are completely determined by the first two of these equations, which can be merged together and integrated to form a governing equation: Wilkins (1972), there are no bound null geodesics that terminate above the horizon, implying that at most there can be one radial turning point along the geodesic path. There are therefore three types of radial motion that we must consider:
from re to ro with no radial turning point encountered, implying either (s1r = +1, s2r =−1) if re < ro or (s1r =−1, s2r =−1) if re > ro;
from re inwards to perihelion at rt, then outwards to ro, implying that (s1r =−1, s2r = +1) for rt < re, rt < ro;
from re outwards to aphelion at rt, then inwards to ro, implying that (s1r = +1, s2r = +1) for rt > re, rt > ro.
For the latitudinal motion we can, in general, have an arbitrary number of turning points occurring along the path (unlike in the radial case). This requires a more complex expression to describe the contribution of the latitudinal motion. We introduce the variable m = cos θ:Rauch & Blandford 1994), while nm denotes the number of such turning points through which the path passes and s1,2m can take the values −1, +1. Specifically, the case of s1m is described by two possibilities:
if m+ =−m−, then s1m = +1, −1 is dependent on whether the path is initially directed towards the ‘north’ or ‘south’ poles of the hole, respectively;
if m+= −m−, then s1m is in the direction of the closest of m+,− to me.
The sign of s2m is determined by the number of turning points, nm, through which the geodesic passes, s2m = −1nm.Rauch & Blandford (1994) tabulate these functions to determine the observed coordinate latitude, θobs, for photons with momenta (λ, q) emitted from a given radius and latitude which arrive at the observer's radial coordinate. Alternatively, Agol (1997) and Cadez et al. (1998) fix one end of the radial path at infinity with some inclination and the coordinates at which the other end crosses the equatorial plane. An additional method, due to Viergutz (1993), fixes the ends of the photon paths at the required coordinates, and a minimization technique is applied to determine valid (λ, q) pairs for a given number of orbits of the black hole.
Our approach combines aspects of those described by Rauch & Blandford (1994) and Viergutz (1993). We invert the reformulated governing equation to obtain the observed coordinate latitude of the geodesic, using the technique described by Rauch & Blandford (1994):Viergutz (1993) to dramatically reduce the scale of the calculation by analytically restricting the range of λ and q to those which can escape to infinity. Then we search this range for those paths which contribute to a given image order at the required observed inclination. These geodesics are then projected to form an image of the system on the observer's sky, which is then used to determined the measured flux (described in Beckwith & Done 2004). The code therefore allows the fast calculation of geodesics linking any two points in the space—time that make a specified number orbits of the black hole.
Zeros of the effective potentials
To obtain solutions of the reformulated governing equation (6), we turn to the tables of elliptic integrals provided by Rauch & Blandford (1994), as modified by Agol (1997). These tables, when combined with appropriate numerical techniques, allow us, in principal, to determine the geodesics that link an arbitrary emitter (re, me) and observer (ro, mo).
In practice, however, this calculation is far from trivial. By specifying the locations of the emitter and receiver, we have placed definite restrictions on the values of the angular momentum parameters, (λ, q) for which geodesic motion between these two locations is even possible. The geodesic motion is dependent on the square root of the two effective potentials, Rλ,q(r), Mλ,q(m), which requires that these functions remain positive definite at all points along the path. If, at any point on the geodesic, this requirement is broken, then a potential barrier is necessarily formed and no such motion is possible. Viergutz (1993) has shown that these requirements can be expressed in terms of the interplay of a set of algebraic functions, which we consider further here. Note that the application of these functions enables us to provide tight limits on the region of parameter space which must be considered in the calculation and hence hugely reduce the scale of the calculation. We begin by introducing
The description of the radial motion is more complex, due to the existence of the unstable photon orbits (Chandrasekhar 1983). These orbits are described by the existence of a further set of zeros of the radial effective potential, Rλ,q(r) = 0, which is subject to the additional constraint ∂rRλ,q(r) = 0. These conditions yield a pair of parametric equations describing a critical curve on the (λ, q) plane, which define the apparent angular size of the black hole:Chandrasekhar (1983), we denote these radii by r(+)ph and r(−)ph and so r(+)ph≤rc≤r(−)ph.
The second complication to this discussion stems from Wilkins (1972). Specifically, for any particle, orbits with E2 > δ2 (where E2 denotes particle energy, and δ2 = 1, 0 particle mass), are unbound, while orbits with E2 < δ2 are bound. Because photons are massless, this implies that the only bound orbits are those with negative E2 (and so must terminate behind the horizon), while all others must be unbound (except for a set of unstable, circular orbits). We cannot therefore (unlike in the previous discussion) consider trajectories with as pericentre and as apocentre.
For our purposes, three particular cases describing the behaviour of the qr,a(λ) curve are of interest. To illustrate these, we consider an extreme Kerr (a = 1) hole, with the observer located at radial infinity and an inclination of θo = 30°. We locate the emitter in the equatorial plane and begin by considering the case (Fig. 1, left panel). Here, the region of the angular momentum (λ, q) plane for which no potential barrier is formed between the emitter and observer is bounded from below by qm,a(λ), as described by equation (11). The upper limit of this region is provided by and it can be shown that, independent of the locations of the emitter and observer, these curves are concave and convex functions of λ, respectively. This indicates that we can provide limits on the allowed range of λ via
The apparent angular size of the black hole is defined by the parametric curve qc(rc), λc(rc). Hence, photons whose angular momentum falls under this curve, and which are directed initially inwards towards the hole from , are inevitably captured. For , this critical curve intersects the graph of qm,a(λ) at some λ+,−c (the exact intersection being determined numerically) and so inwardly directed photons with λ−c≤λ≤λ+c, qm,a(λ) ≤q≤qc(rc), where rc is determined by inversion of λ =λc(rc), can be completely excluded from the calculation.
We now move the location of the emitter inwards such that (Fig. 1, centre panel). We have that the valid region of the angular momentum plane is bounded from below by qm,a(λ), as before. The behaviour of the upper bound to the angular momentum plane is however quite different. In this case, because , there exists some , which is associated with a (λ*c, q*c) pair, through equations (12). For λ≤λ*c, we therefore have that the upper limit of the angular momentum plane is given by the critical curve, and hence the lower limit on λ is determined by λ+c. Similarly, above λ*c, the upper limit on the plane is given, as in the previous case, by , and so the upper limit on λ is given by . Note that, for λ≤λ*c, there are no photons that are emitted on radially inbound geodesics that reach the observer, while for λ > λ*c, only those initially in-going photons with values of q above the critical curve can reach the observer. Finally, we note that for the emitter located at (Fig. 1 right-hand panel), the graph of qr,a(λ) is now concave. However, the relationship between the various curves remains unchanged from that described in the previous case, and the angular momentum plane remains bound.
Structure and properties of loops on the (λq) plane
We begin by considering solutions to the ‘governing’ equation for a simple system where the emitter is located in the equatorial plane of an extreme Kerr (a = 1) hole (θe = π/2) and takes the form of an infinitesimal ring located at radius re. For such an infinitesimal ring, the flux is undefined (because the ring subtends zero solid angle on the observer's sky) and so we concentrate our attention on the behaviour of the solutions on the (λ, q) and (α, β) planes (Fig. 2). To minimize the impact of gravitational lensing, we locate the observer at radial infinity and θo = 30° (as previously).
Initially, we locate the ring at re = 8rg (Fig. 2, leftmost panel) and catalogue the complete set of geodesics of zeroth (N = 0), first (N = 1) and second (N = 2) orders. Each of these geodesic orders forms a closed loop on both the (λ, q) and (α, β) planes. We note that the projections on both planes are asymmetric about the line λ, α = 0 due to the breaking of spherical symmetry by the black hole spin and also (for the emitter located at 8rg) that the loops for each individual image order are completely detached. We now move the emitter inwards to re = 6rg (Fig. 2, second from left panel), which causes the loops associated with the zeroth- and first-order images to overlap. The solutions to the geodesic equations are therefore multivalued at these points in (λ, q) space, contradicting the statement by Cunningham (1975) that there are two geodesics linking a point on the accretion disc to an observer for each value of the redshift parameter, g, which (for the Keplerian disc considered by Cunningham) corresponds to two geodesics at each valid point in λ space. If we now move the emitter inwards to re = 4rg (Fig. 2, third from left panel), we now see that the loops associated with the zeroth-order geodesic now overlap with both the first-order and second-order loops.
We now move the emitter further inwards, so that r(+)ph≤re = 3rg < r(−)ph (Fig. 2, third from right panel). Here, the zeroth-order loop still overlaps the first-order and second-order loops; however, in this case the first- and second-order loops now touch. Moving the emitter inwards still further to re = 2rg (Fig. 2, second from right panel), the zeroth-order loop now detaches itself from the first- and second-order loops and moves inside these loops on the (α, β) plane projection. The apparent angular size of the zeroth-order loop, as measured by the distant observer, is now smaller than that of the first- and second-order loops, which has important consequences for the calculation of the emergent flux, as we shall shortly see. Finally, we move the emitter down to re−rg = 10−6 (Fig. 2, rightmost panel), the location of r+ in Boyer—Lindquist coordinates (however, this is not the case in terms of proper distance; see Bardeen, Press & Teukolsky 1972). All of the loops are again detached; however, in comparison to the case where re = 8rg, the ordering of these loops is now reversed on the (α, β) plane, with the second order now subtending the greatest angular size of the observer's sky.
We now replace the central extreme Kerr black hole with a Schwarzschild (a = 0) black hole and repeat the preceding calculation. From Fig. 3, we see that the behaviour of the solutions on the two planes is qualitatively similar to that of the extreme Kerr case as we move the emitter from 8rg down to 4rg. However, in this case we note that the loops are now symmetric about the line λ, α = 0 due to the absence of rotation in the system, and this results in the quantitative locations of the overlap to change. Note that we can understand the existence of these overlaps by considering the meaning of the projection of these loops on the (λ, q) plane. Recall that, for a given (λ, q) pair, there exists a set of roots (ri, mi) of the effective potentials Rλ,q(r), Mλ,q(m). Whether or not the geodesic path passes through selected members of these sets of roots depends on the initial direction taken by the geodesic, described by the sr, sm parameters in equation (6), and hence different geodesic paths can be described by a single (λ, q) pair.
Consider now the behaviour of these loops as we move the emitter to re = 3rg for the Schwarzschild hole (Fig. 3, third from right panel). Here, we find that the zeroth- and first-order loops are now detached, but in this case the second-order loop does not exist. Moving the emitter in further to 2.5rg (Fig. 3, second from right panel), we find that not only does the first-order loop disappear, but the zeroth-order loop is no longer closed. Finally, if we move the emitter to re− 2rg = 10−6 (Fig. 3, rightmost panel), then we find that we are only able to image a small line segment from the ring. To understand this behaviour, we turn to the discussion given by Chandrasekhar (1983) regarding the ‘cone of avoidance’, describing the cone generated the photons that pass through the unstable circular orbits located at 3rg. We let ψ denote the half-angle of the cone (directed inward at large distances from the hole) and it can then be shown that
General emission geometries
In the standard picture of accretion on to a massive compact object, the emitting material is located in the equatorial plane in what is assumed to be a geometrically thin structure. As such, gravitational lensing effects only come into play for high-inclination systems (θo > 60°). However, if one wishes to consider emission from a non-equatorial geometry (the case of a geometrically thick, optically thin accretion flow, for example), then gravitational lensing effects can have important consequences even for low-inclination observers. As an example, consider again two infinitesimal rings, located at re = 6rg, with polar coordinates θae = 149° and θbe = 151°. We again locate the observer at radial infinity and initially take θo = 25° such that |θo| < |θa,be| (Fig. 4, left panel). The two rings are mapped continuously on to the (α, β) plane for each individual image order in a similar fashion to those considered previously. We now move the latitudinal coordinate of the observer to θo = 30°, such that |θae| < |θo| < |θbe| (Fig. 4, centre panel). The image of the lower ring, θbe is again mapped continuously on to the (α, β) plane for each individual image order, as would be expected as its relationship to the latitudinal coordinate of the observer has remained unchanged. This is not true however of the image of the upper ring, θae, which is now mapped discontinuously on to the (α, β) plane, with the even image orders (zeroth and second) appearing from the Southern hemisphere of the hole and the odd image orders (first) appearing from the Northern hemisphere. It is therefore clear that, in order to generate a complete picture of the physical properties of such a system, we must include the contribution of the higher orders to the calculation. Finally, we again move the observer in the latitudinal direction to θo = 35°, such that |θo| > |θa,be| (Fig. 4, right panel). Now the images of both rings are mapped discontinuously on to the (α, β) plane, which serves to further emphasize the importance of the inclusion of the higher-order images in the calculation.
Results and Discussion
Images of thin Keplerian accretion discs
The contribution of higher-order images to the observed flux is dependent both on the location of the observer and the angular momentum of the hole itself, together with the assumed geometry and emissivity of the accretion flow. For an optically thick accretion disc then, any photons which reintersect the disc after emission will be either absorbed (and then re-emitted) or reflected by the material. Fig. 5 shows the contributions of both the direct (N = 0) and higher-order (N = 1, 2) images of a geometrically thin disc extending from rms to 20rg, viewed at θo = 15° for both Schwarzschild and extreme Kerr black holes. The principal effect of black hole spin for the accretion disc dynamics is to move the location of the marginally stable orbit, rms and hence the location of the inner edge of the accretion disc. In the case of the Schwarzschild hole, the apparent location (as measured by a distant observer; see Fig. 5, top row) of the direct image of the accretion disc is further from the origin than the higher-order images, resulting in a distinct ‘gap’ where no photons are received by the observer. By contrast, for an extreme Kerr black hole, the apparent location of the inner edge of the direct image coincides with that of the higher-order images and so this gap is no longer present. Hence, for high spin black holes a large fraction of the higher-order image flux returns to the inner regions of the accretion disc. Note that the range of accessible redshifts is far narrower for the Schwarzschild disc than for the extreme Kerr case, due to the inner edge of the accretion disc (the marginally stable orbit) being located far deeper in the gravitational potential in the latter.
Fig. 6 shows the same systems viewed at a range of large inclination angles, . As in the previous discussion for the Schwarzschild hole, the inner edge of the accretion disc is located above the location of the photon orbits and hence the majority of the orbiting photons are able to propagate freely to the observer. However, photons in the first-order image of the far side of the disc now have paths which pass rather closer to the hole than at lower inclination, so the importance of lensing is increased, strongly amplifying this part of the image. Most of these photons cross the equatorial plane at r≧ 20rg, and so can be seen in our simulation but would be obscured by a more physically realistic disc, which is not entirely flat and has outer edge r ≫ 20rg. These photons instead would illuminate a large region of the underside of the disc as the direct image of the disc, adding to its intrinsic emission. By contrast, the area on the sky of the second-order image remains approximately constant with increasing inclination, reflecting the sensitivity (i.e. instability) of the two-loop photon orbits.
The high-inclination extreme Kerr images are shown in Fig. 6 (bottom row). The disc itself blocks all the higher orbit images close to the black hole, similar to the θo = 15° case. Part of the first-order image where the geodesic crosses the equatorial plane at r≧ 20rg can be seen, and this fraction increases with increasing inclination of the observer. Indeed, for the highest-inclination system considered in this work, the apparent angular size of the first-order image is approximately equivalent to that subtended by the direct image. In contrast to the Schwarzschild case, we note that the images of the extreme Kerr system are strongly asymmetric about the horizontal axis due to the effect of the black hole spin, with the degree of this asymmetry increasing with the inclination of the observer. This asymmetry is most pronounced for the (unobscured) first- and second-order images generated from the highest-inclination system (see Fig. 7). Here, the effect of the range of radii for orbiting photons can be seen most clearly in the second-order image. The image is offset from zero as those on the left are the photons which are emitted from the side of the disc approaching the observer, and so go with the spin of the black hole and orbit at rg, while photons on the right are the retrograde ones at 4rg. The hole in the inner disc is symmetric at rg, so it (just) obscures all the prograde photons and easily obscures the retrograde ones. A small decrease in spin (e.g. to a = 0.998, the equilibrium spin for thin disc accretion) increases rms to 1.23, while the photon orbits span 1.07–3.998rg; thus, a small part of the prograde higher-order image can be seen. The fraction of higher-order photons which can escape through the ‘hole’ decreases with increasing spin until a≲ 0.65, where the apparent location of the photon orbits is above that of the inner edge of the accretion disc (Bardeen et al. 1972).
Spectral properties of higher-order images
To understand how the astrophysical properties of the accretion flow couple to the gravitational field of the black hole, we generate relativistically smeared line profiles as described in Beckwith & Done (2004). For clarity, we briefly recap this method here. We consider an intrinsically narrow emission line with rest energy, Ee, for which the flux distribution measured by a distant observer at an energy Eo is given by
To generate the line profiles, we apply a radial emissivity of the form ∈(re) ∝r−3e (consistent with gravitational energy release within the disc; Zycki, Done & Smith 1999) and consider three possible angular emissivity laws: (i) f(μe) ∝ constant, corresponding to an optically thick disc (red lines); (ii) f(μe) ∝μ−1e, corresponding to an optically thin, limb brightened disc (blue lines) (Matt, Perola & Stella 1993); (iii) f(μe) ∝ (1 + 2.06μe) corresponding to an optically thick, limb darkened disc (green lines) (Laor et al. 1990). Fig. 8 shows the line profiles generated for the low-inclination Schwarzschild disc discussed in the preceding section. While, in the case of the extreme Kerr black hole (Fig. 5, bottom row), all orbiting photons returned to the inner region of the disc, for the Schwarzschild hole (Fig. 5, top row) these photons cross the equatorial plane below rms and can freely propagate to the observer (although see Reynolds & Begelman 1997). Examination of their spectral properties shows that these photons play a limited role in forming the overall spectral shape measured by a distant observer, which is completely dominated by the contribution from the direct image.
Fig. 9 shows the line profiles generated for a Schwarzschild hole, with the accretion disc now viewed at high inclination (ignoring the effect of obscuration). For the direct image, limb darkening boosts the effects of gravitational lensing, enhancing the flux from the far side of the hole. This is because these photons are strongly bent, i.e. they are emitted from a lower inclination angle than that at which they are observed, so a limb darkening law means that the flux here is higher (Beckwith & Done 2004). The Doppler shifts are rather small for this material, so this lensing enhances the flux in the middle of the line. Because the line profiles are normalized to unity, this means that the blue wing is less dominant.
The first-order spectra are shown in Fig. 9 (middle row). The transfer functions mostly retain the characteristic double-peaked and skewed shape, and again the principal effect of the different angular emissivities is to alter the balance between the blue wing and lensed middle of the line. However, there is some new behaviour for the limb brightened emissivity. This has the largest change in emissivity with angle, and this, combined with the exquisite sensitivity of lensed paths, means that this picks out only a small area on the disc, leading to a discrete feature in the spectrum. These profiles also show enhancement of the extreme red wing of the line, as the photons which orbit generally are emitted from the very innermost radii of the disc.
The discrete features are completely dominant for all emissivities at second order (Fig. 9, bottom row). These are images of the top of the disc where the photons have orbited the black hole, so the paths are even more sensitive to small changes than first order. Thus, the profiles are significantly more complex in structure, being dominated by lensing. There are blue and red features at the extreme ends of the line profile which are picking out the maximum projected velocity of the innermost radii of the disc. These have the standard blue peak enhancement. However, the two strong features redward of this are a pair of lensed features, from the near and far sides of the disc.
Fig. 10 shows the line profiles generated for the extreme Kerr black hole at high inclinations, again ignoring the effect of obscuration. For the direct image (Fig. 10, top row), the lines exhibit the characteristic triangular shape previously reported by, for example, Laor (1991), with the variation in angular emissivity acting to alter the balance between the different regions of the line on a ∼5 per cent level. The lines associated with the first-order image (Fig. 10, middle row) exhibit a marked difference in comparison to those associated with the Schwarzschild black hole. In general, they are broader than those associated with the direct image and resemble a skewed Gaussian combined with a narrow line (due to caustic formation) at g≈ 1.0. Here, the principal effect of changes in the angular emissivity is to alter the height of the blue wing, relative to the rest of the line. Again, the line profiles associated with the second-order image (Fig. 10, bottom row) are completely dominated by discrete features, as in the Schwarzschild case.
To understand the relative roles played by each (unobscured) image order, we consider the variation of the luminosity of each image as a fraction of the total luminosity of the system as a function of inclination, again for both Schwarzschild and extreme Kerr black holes (Fig. 11). These luminosities are generated from the integral in redshift space of the line profiles considered in the preceding section, and hence we consider systems with identical properties to those previously discussed. In the case of the Schwarzschild black hole, we see that, for inclinations <80°, the first-order image can be regarded as a ≤10 per cent correction to the emergent flux from the system. For inclinations ≧80°, this image contains 10–20 per cent of the emergent flux, i.e. even at these high inclinations the first-order image can still be regarded as a correction to the direct image. For the second-order image, we see that it plays a ≤1 per cent role independent of inclination. Third- and higher-order images will have correspondingly smaller fluxes, and so can safely be neglected.
There is a larger fraction of flux in the higher-order images for the Kerr black hole. At low inclinations, the first- and second-order images contain 10 and 1 per cent of the total flux, respectively. The variation of the luminosity fraction for the three image orders displays an approximately power-law-like behaviour for inclinations ≤60°, where a distinct break occurs, due to the appearance of a caustic in the first-order image, whose luminosity is therefore significantly enhanced. It is at this point that the peak luminosity of the second-order image occurs, which here is of the level of 10 per cent, approximately an order of magnitude higher than in the Schwarzschild case. Remarkably, for inclinations >75°, the luminosity of the first-order image produced by the optically thick discs is greater than that produced by the direct image.
However, most of the higher image order flux is expected to reintercept the disc plane, and hence be absorbed and reradiated. This is especially the case for realistic discs around an extreme Kerr black hole, where the whole of the equatorial plane is covered by the disc from rg to large radii. However, for a Schwarzschild black hole, the existence of a central ‘hole’ means that the flux from higher-order images can escape. A realistic disc around a Schwarzschild black hole when viewed face-on has 10 per cent of its flux in a higher-order image ring (dropping to ∼7 per cent for a more extended disc ranging from rms → 400rg). Essentially, a spatial resolution equivalent to 2rg is required to resolve these features, which for typical nearby AGNs corresponds to an angular resolution of 0.01 μarcsec. This is obviously extremely technically difficult, but is feasible for an X-ray interferometer imaging supermassive black holes in nearby galaxies (Gendreau et al. 2001).
Photons orbiting a black hole are exquisitely sensitive to the properties of the gravitational field. Thus, these higher-order null geodesics provide the best test of Einstein's gravity in the strong field limit. We have developed a new strong gravity code capable of describing these paths, and we calculate them for a geometrically thin, optically thick (standard) disc in both Schwarzschild and Kerr metrics. These higher-order image paths must cross the equatorial plane, and so are absorbed where this is filled by the optically thick disc. As has long been known, the major amplification effects of gravitational lensing are for the first-order paths from the far side of the underneath of the disc viewed at high inclination, i.e. photons initially emitted downwards on the far side of the black hole, which are bent by gravity up above the disc plane. Most of these paths will reintersect the disc unless it has very limited outer radial extent. While such discs may exist (Reynolds et al. 2004), it seems far more likely that these photons would be absorbed by material in the equatorial plane. However, there is some fraction of the higher-order images where the light paths are so strongly bent that they reintersect the equatorial plane very close to the photon orbit radius. By definition, this is below the minimum stable orbit for particles, so the standard disc cannot exist at this point. Instead, for a stress-free inner boundary condition, the disc material plunges rapidly through this region, so there is much less absorbing material in the equatorial plane. This material may be optically thick at high mass accretion rates (Reynolds & Begelman 1997), but this depends on whether the flow in the plunging region is smooth or clumpy. Hence, higher-order photons which cross the plane below 6rg need not be reabsorbed by the disc. We show that these observable higher-order photons can carry 10 per cent of the flux for a face-on disc. Edge-on discs reduce the expected observable flux as only about half of the orbiting photon ring can be seen through the gap below rms, while the rest reintercepts the disc at r ≫rms.
The situation is less favourable in the Kerr geometry as photons now orbit at a range of radii depending on how their angular momentum is aligned with the spin of the black hole. Photons going against the spin will orbit at radii which are larger than that of the minimum stable orbit of the disc, and so should be absorbed rather than escaping through the inner ‘hole’ in the disc (provided a ≳ 0.65). Thus, for Kerr black holes, even though there is a greater fraction of photons in the higher-order images, we expect that these are less observable due to the overlap between the photon and particle orbits. Also, even though there is still a gap between the last stable particle orbit and the aligned photon orbits, this gap is much smaller than in a Schwarzschild black hole, both in terms of radial coordinate and in terms of impact parameter on the sky. For a = 0.998, the equilibrium spin for thin disc accretion, rms = 1.23rg while the r(−)ph = 1.07, so Δr = 0.16. Because the photons orbit in slightly stronger gravity, their paths are more distorted, so the difference in their impact parameter at infinity is slightly less than the difference in radial coordinate. Thus, the higher-order images round a rapidly spinning black hole are much more difficult to spatially resolve from the direct image of the disc, and carry less flux than in the Schwarzschild case as only a fraction reintersect the plane below rms.
Thus, the best chance of observing these higher-order photon paths from a standard accretion disc is with a face-on Schwarzschild black hole. X-ray interferometry could potentially directly resolve such scales for supermassive black holes in nearby galaxies, and such missions are being seriously proposed (MAXIM; Gendreau et al. 2001). Even if the plunging region is optically thick, direct imaging with resolution ≤2rg will clearly show the black hole spin from the apparent size of the ‘hole’ in the centre of the disc. The radial coordinate of the innermost stable orbit in an equilibrium spin Kerr metric is a factor of ∼3 smaller than for the Schwarzschild case, which translates to a change in apparent size at infinity of the ‘hole’ diameter from ∼5rg(a = 0.998) to ∼14rg (a = 0). This is important, as recent papers have emphasized that the true size of the shadow of the event horizon (in effect the impact parameter of the orbiting photons, given fairly accurately by our second-order image) is rather similar in both Schwarzschild and Kerr cases (Falcke et al. 2000; Fukue 2003; Takahashi 2004). This is true, but different to the size of the ‘hole’ defined by the innermost stable orbit of the disc. For continuous energy release down to the event horizon, the ‘hole’ in the image of the accretion flow is set by the true shadow size, but for accretion flows where the energy is only released from stable particle orbits (the disc, as opposed to the plunging region) then the innermost stable orbit sets the size scale. Whether the energy release can be continuous across rms is currently a matter of active research (Krolik & Hawley 2002). However, there is clear observational evidence for an innermost stable orbit in the disc-dominated spectra of galactic black hole binaries (Ebisawa et al. 1993; Kubota et al. 1999; Gierliński & Done 2004), so it seems likely that the accretion flow can take the standard thin disc form assumed here.
The spectral signatures of these higher-order photons only become apparent for high-inclination systems, where they carry between ∼20 per cent (Schwarzschild) and ∼60 per cent (extreme Kerr) of the total luminosity of the system. However, in a realistic system, the disc extends out to many thousands of gravitational radii from the black hole, and so these photons return to the disc before reaching the observer. Far from the central black hole, the effect of the returning radiation is comparable to the gravitational potential energy of the material, and so these photons can play an important role in shaping the properties of the disc here. In particular, reprocessing of this returning radiation at large distances from the hole will potentially provide a physical mechanism to flatten (at large radii) the r−3/4 temperature profile of a planar accretion disc irradiated by a central source, which could help to resolve the conflict between the predicted and observed optical/ultraviolet colours in AGNs (Koratkar & Blaes 1999).
The code used to calculate these results is an extension of that of Beckwith & Done (2004). The new aspect described here is a set of analytical constraints on the possible photon trajectories, which vastly reduce the scale of the calculation. This, combined with the use of the analytical integrals (elliptic functions) for the photon paths, has the result that the calculation of a photon trajectory linking two points (the emitter and observer; Viergutz 1993) can be performed by a simple minimization, capable of being calculated to almost arbitrary accuracy on a standard desktop PC on time-scales of a few minutes. This technique allows us to include the contribution of orbiting photons in the calculations without loss of resolution. The code is also flexible enough to be adapted to any accretion flow, and a future paper will consider the contribution of the higher-order images in an optically thin, geometrically thick flow.
We would like to thank the referee, Dr V Karas, for his time and effort in helping to improve the original form of the manuscript.